Rail strikes are the symptom, not the cause, of the problem

CROYDON COMMENTARY: Like thousands of other local commuters, CATHERINE SHELLEY has been affected by the long-running rail dispute. She says that the real problem lies with Southern Rail’s mismanagement, aided by the Tory Government

On a weekday evening at Victoria Station shortly before Christmas, and not for the first time, a series of trains was cancelled, one after the other. A young mum on the platform, who was going to be delayed collecting her young son went into meltdown with the panic and frustration of the situation.

Commuters crowd the platforms at East Croydon during the last day of strike action. The operator is more interested in increased profits than passengers' safety

Commuters crowd the platforms at East Croydon

Other passengers got angry too and surrounded a pair of female southern rail staff. The staff were also upset as they, too, were trying to get to Clapham Junction for their next shift, just as frustrated as the rest of the crowds on the platform.

The Tannoy announced that the cancellations were caused by drivers not being available, giving the impression that they were having a break or hadn’t turned up for work. In fact, the drivers were all stuck on other trains, trying to get back to Victoria after untold other delays and breakdowns earlier in the day.

If you travel on Southern Rail services, you will recognise this situation and all too often the frontline staff of the train companies get the blame and end up being abused by frustrated and angry commuters. Yet they are trapped in this mess just as much as any passenger, trying their best to make an impossible situation work.

Staff and passengers are in this together.

The daily disruption to services on non-strike days is evidence that the strikes are not the real issue. The management’s approach of criticising staff for not working overtime and continually blaming the drivers for not being available when that is often beyond their control is no way to address the problems of Southern Rail.

The Government deliberately designed the agreement with Govia Thameslink, who operate Southern, so that their profits don’t suffer no matter how bad the service gets. This means they have no incentive to reach any settlement or even negotiate with unions. And so the dispute continues to drag on.

The hypocrisy of the Government’s approach is clear. When the private owners cut corners and let the service fall apart month after month, the Government refuses to intervene. But as soon staff working on our railways act to protect our safety, Tory MPs start demanding that strikes should be banned because the railways are a vital public service.

We understand that strikes cause disruption for commuters, but the industrial action is a symptom, not the cause, of the problems on our railways.

The people working on the railways can see how the cuts to staff and changes to working practices are reducing levels of service and increasing the risk of accidents. The issue of driver-only trains is only one concern; to run a service dependent on staff working significant overtime also carries obvious safety implications. That is why we in the Croydon and Sutton Green Party support their industrial action.

The railways are a vital public service and so they should be run in the interests of all of us – passengers and staff – and not just to make profits for shareholders and pay bonuses to overpaid CEOs.

It’s time to end the failed privatisation model and start providing the railway service we all want and need. You can sign our petition here to bring control and accountability for rail services back into public hands.

  • Catherine Shelley is the co-chair of Croydon and Sutton Greens

  • Inside Croydon is Croydon’s only independent news source, still based in the heart of the borough. In 2016, we averaged 17,000 page views every week
  • If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, a residents’ or business association or a local event to publicise, please email us with full details at inside.croydon@btinternet.com

About insidecroydon

News, views and analysis about the people of Croydon, their lives and political times in the diverse and most-populated borough in London. Based in Croydon and edited by Steven Downes. To contact us, please email inside.croydon@btinternet.com
This entry was posted in Catherine Shelley, Commuting, Croydon Greens, East Croydon, Transport and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Rail strikes are the symptom, not the cause, of the problem

  1. Congratulations Catherine on a very well balanced non-left wing appraisal !! Utter tosh.
    Everyone except Catherine knows this is nothing to do with safety. And by everyone I include all of the members of the rail union who are carrying out this politically motivated strike.
    The deal Govia has with the government is wrong, however the premise of drivers operating doors is proven to be perfectly safe, indeed the unions themselves, when it suits them agree with this.
    The bloody unions goaded on by Corbyn are a bloody disgrace.

Leave a Reply to David Hamilton Cancel reply