Carillion, the building company which somehow landed the contract to run Croydon’s public libraries, is so strapped for cash that they have unpaid bills from their suppliers for use of photo-copiers and paper.
Carillion is a construction company which was seeking juicy profits by grabbing outsourced libraries
The value of the company’s shares plunged a further 30 per cent this morning, as the troubled firm issued the latest in a series of profit warnings and trading updates.
Carillion announced to the London Stock Exchange that it is to try to recapitalise, it downgraded profit expectations, and revealed higher than anticipated debts and said it expected to be in breach of covenants – agreements to pay loans – by the end of the year.
Carillion’s problems relate mostly to its construction business, but it is having a knock-on effect to the subsidiary which is running Croydon’s and other local authority libraries.
The state of the business prompted one City analyst to say this morning, “The Carillion horror show continues.”
Nicholas Hyett, an equity analyst with Hargreaves Lansdown, having reviewed the company statement, said, “The group has made some progress on asset sales, and it sounds like some cost savings are being made. It’s not what the group expected though, and it’s clearly not enough.
“It’s also probably irrelevant given the state of the balance sheet, with net debt already many multiples of the group’s market capitalisation.”
That’s not good news for Croydon’s libraries. There have already been a string of complaints from residents and councillors about the lack of proper maintenance of the buildings or the book stock. Now, printers and copiers in the borough’s public libraries are not being serviced if they break down, because of the unpaid bills with suppliers.
Carillion took over the running of Croydon’s 13 public libraries at the end of 2013.
The then Tory-run council had run a bungled privatisation programme. After handing the contract to their mates at a subsidiary of John Laing (the construction firm that built the council offices at Fisher’s Folly at vast expense), it then got shovelled off to Carillion – who had never participated in the formal tendering process. Within weeks, Carillion were laying off experienced and valued library staff.
Carillion’s poor service in local authority libraries has already seen then sacked by Hounslow, which has taken its library service back in-house, something which Croydon’s cabinet member for art and culture, Timothy Godfrey, is keen to do here. But sources at the Town Hall suggest that all moves to cancel Carillion’s contract – which has three years to run – are being resisted by the council’s “we know best” professional staff.
Last month, Godfrey said that our libraries’ front-line staff and local management “don’t get the support that they deserve” from Carillion.
“If they do collapse then we at Croydon Council will keep the libraries open and transfer all the front-line staff back to the council.
“In the meantime, the residents of Croydon get a sub-standard service and not the libraries we all deserve.
“Carillion are hanging on to their library contracts – three boroughs are left after they lost the contract to run Hounslow libraries. Croydon’s contract has three years left to run, and the council is worried that if it ends the contract early then it will have to pay compensation to Carillion.
“As a result of Carillion losing their Hounslow contract, our online library lost book stock, which we have been promised will be replenished at no cost to Croydon Council.”
Things must be tough for Carillion now, though, if they are so short of cash that they are failing to pay their bills in Croydon’s libraries. Yet again, it is the front-line staff and the library users who are suffering as a consequence of Tory austerity efforts at cost-cutting, rather than taking real pride in delivering outstanding public services.
Inside Croydon is a member of the Independent Community News Network- Inside Croydon is the borough’s only independent news source, and still based in the heart of Croydon
- 1 MILLION PAGE VIEWS IN 2017 (January to September)
- If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, a residents’ or business association or a local event to publicise, please email us with full details at inside.croydon@btinternet.com
Carillion are also cutting library services in Croydon. As Chair of the Croydon Disability Forum I am still waiting for an explanation of why they are withdrawing the very valuable Home Library Service from everyone except those who are housebound and have nobody to assist them to collect books. A large number of disable and elderly residents who are not housebound are still unable to access a Library (or carry books) and the home Library service is a vital service for them and helps overcome some problems of social isolation. It is pure discrimination due to thoughtless cost cutting.
Pingback: Cash-strapped Carillion can’t pay their library paper bills | Inside Croydon – leftwingnobody
Thanks to Tory and New-Labour obession with neoliberal ideology, Croydon’s libraries join the ranks of our leisure centres, parks, schools, public housing and rail links as cash commodities to be run badly by outsourcing/contractor cowboys addicted to public subsidy, the bloodsuckers
Libraries should be run by librarians! So – Carillion doesn’t know how to budget. Another one……. The library ID card should show payment for printing due, and should be enforced. The photos say it all; what a bl**dy mess. No idea how to run a library. Who does the classification? Who decides what to buy for the target audience? Who decides when to remove/archive books and other media? Or do they throw it all in a skip (not a first) without any evaluation? Who does the insurance valuation for the library? Do they know the replacement value? Are there any rare books kicking around that should be held in fire-proof cabinets? CARILLION obviously doesn’t want to hire a professional for each library. It prefers a pigs’ ear, and a system that nobody can use. BTW, I’m allowed an opinion because I am a librarian.
Fine. Bring them back in house. Pay the penalty for the contract break, and the extra revenue costs to bring the service up to where people think it should be.
Now, where are you going to fund this from? Reserves and balances are low. The in year position is under pressure, so no relief there.
Children’s social care is getting (and probably needs) a blank cheque.
So that leaves:
– adult social care?
-send transport?
-school improvement?
-homelessness support?
-further cuts to admin support/ opening hours?
-further reductions in parks/sport?
-or maybe highways repair and structure maintenance?
-Or cut waste and street cleaning?
-put up parking and waste fees perhaps?
-or stop the work to try and help businesses grow.
-or what about cut some of the unimportant services that no-one really talks about, like planning enforcement, environmental health, dangerous structures enforcement, preventative work with families, respite care for carers etc.
And if all of those are unpalatable, tax payers might be willing to pay an extra 2% tax a year? the maximum available increase for non adult social care services.
It’s not just Carillion who have to budget…
I’m sure councillors didn’t join up to cut things, but if the money isn’t there, then the simple fact is that the same level of activity can not be delivered. Not unless some more effective ways of delivering services is found.
I do think an in sourced service would be better, but I doubt it would be cheaper.