Huge: the Royal Festival Hall and the South Bank Centre. In Lambeth, which is south London
In the latest embarrassing blow for the council-owned arts centre, the Fairfield Halls has received a warning from the Advertising Standards Authority over repeatedly making misleading and false claims to be “south London’s biggest arts centre”.
The official reproach ought to be an object lesson to the promotions company running the venue that they really should never believe the lies of third-rate local politicians.
The Fairfield Halls re-opened last September after a late-running and vastly over-budget refurbishment and has since struggled to draw in big audiences.
Not as big: the Fairfield Halls
They have cancelled shows in the new “Wreck” performance space, and last month the artistic director quit his job, as BHLive, the company which operates the venue on behalf of the council, seeks to go more downmarket, looking at offering all-in wrestling and more tribute acts.
When the Fairfield re-opened, it used the bogus claim about being the biggest arts centre in south London on posters plastered on rubbish bins and on the back of bus stops around the town centre.
It also had banners made with the claim, which hang from lampposts all along George Street.
And even last month, as BHLive issued a press release with details of its programme of entertainments at the Fairfield Halls over the coming year, they shamelessly repeated the bogus claim.
Big lie: the Fairfield Halls posters with the false claim
Maybe, being as BHLive are based in Bournemouth, they don’t realise that the South Bank Centre is also in south London. Though, to be fair, there is a clue in the name.
The Fairfield’s bogus claim echoes a boast made in the Town Hall chamber before the venue closed for refurbishment in June 2016, when council leader Tony Newman said that when it re-opened, the Halls would be “bigger and better than the South Bank”.
That claim was clearly bullshit at the time, and now the Advertising Standards Authority has stepped in to stop BHLive repeating the false claim.
The ASA – whose own motto is: “Legal, decent, honest and truthful” – responded to a complaint from the public, and this week they confirmed that they had been in touch with BHLive about the false claim.
The ASA told the complainant: “We’ve assessed the ad you highlighted and, from the information we have, we think it likely to have breached the Advertising Rules that we administer. We are writing to let you know that we have taken steps to address this.
Banners with the misleading claim remain on George Street this week
“We have explained your concerns to the advertiser and provided guidance to them on the areas that require attention, together with advice on how to ensure that their advertising complies with the rules.”
The ASA added that they had “provided guidance” to BHLive “to explain that before distributing or submitting a marketing communication for publication, marketers must hold documentary evidence to prove claims that consumers are likely to regard as objective and that are capable of objective substantiation.
“Furthermore, any ads which include a comparison with an identifiable competitor must be verifiable.”
There was no immediate sign this week that the Fairfield Halls had done anything to remove their false claims – which remain written in large type on the banners draped along George Street, the main route from East Croydon Station to the venue.
And while the ASA reproach may be a minor consideration given the other, major disappointments facing Croydon town centre recently, the past fortnight’s news does mean that Croydon’s council leader Tony Newman now will be denied having south London’s biggest shopping centre, and nor will his council be able to boast of having south London’s biggest arts centre any longer.
In some respects, that’s probably just as well.
As he approaches the conclusion of his mayoral year, Councillor Humayun Kabir is hoping to raise loads of dosh with a charity concert at the Fairfield Halls on Saturday.
Plenty of seats available for Saturday night
But even with tickets for just a tenner (or 30 quid if you want some prosecco and nibbles on the Sun Lounge beforehand), and with just 48 hours to go, the Fairfield Halls site shows a considerable number of places in the 1,500-seater auditorium still available to book.
And that’s with the balcony closed off and not available.
Imagine how empty the place might have looked come Saturday if the Fairfield Halls really was south London’s biggest arts venue…
Croydon, it should be noted, was awarded £1.3million by Mayor Sadiq Khan last month towards being London’s Borough of Culture in 2023. Hopefully, by then, all claims made for the borough will be legal, decent, honest and truthful.
- If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, or what to publicise your residents’ association or business, or if you have a local event to promote, please email us with full details at inside.croydon@btinternet.com
Inside Croydon is a member of the Independent Community News Network- Inside Croydon works together with the Bureau of Investigative Journalism and BBC London News
- Inside Croydon named Journalist of the Year at 2018 Anna Kennedy Online Autism Heroes Awards
- ROTTEN BOROUGH AWARDS: For three consecutive years, 2017, 2018 and 2019, Inside Croydon has been the source for award-winning nominations in Private Eye magazine’s annual celebration of civic cock-ups
- Inside Croydon had 1.6million pages viewed by 721,000 unique visitors in 2019
Lets stop knocking the Fairfield Halls, it needs our support and patronage. Since it reopened I have been there many times. Two visits were a total sell out; John Ritter with the RPO and Sheku Kanneh-Mason with the LMP. The Concert Hall is a world class venue and should be celebrated not derided. The seating in the Hall is much improved and in The Ashcroft theatre it is brand new. My only gripe is that there is little evidence of advertising or promotion. Local rail stations and transport links should be plastered with info about the Fairfield.
Perhaps you could encourage them not to lie in their ads, then?
Do people really have nothing better to do than grass their local arts centre up to the ASA for pomposity? Yes their claim is sadly deluded/stupid but its even sadder filling in an online form to complain… I can’t believe the Fairfield Halls imagining it’s self to be bigger than the South Bank was really doing anyone any serious harm.
It’s a lie, Tony. Which, in advertising, is against the law.
You’re defending a lie. A council-instigated lie at that.
We need to buy our tickets and become patrons of the re-born Fairfield, and go to the events, concerts, theatre, wrestling, etc. We need a variety of entertainment to meet the varied tastes of the people who make up the eclectic mix that is Croydon’s and S. London/ adjacent areas’ community. I myself am looking forward to my first 3 ticketed events, one per month, starting this month, plus a few (free!) lunchtime classical concerts.
Also, with the point about advertising and promotion.
Walking to a consultation event a few weeks ago, about the re-design of the Fair Field (aka College Green) Open space recently (and thanks to Inside Croydon for mentioning this along with the John Grindrod Croydon concrete architecture walks), I crossed the road from the now sadly visually shrunken and overshadowed Queens Gardens and approached the Halls.
There used to be huge advert posters on the front which, while detracting from the architecture, did have the positive effect of announcing upcoming performances to the passer-by.
I would love to see a modern version of this –but not on the hall itself for the same reason– in the form of a suitably scaled free-standing coloured, double-sided LED display unit stationed on the forecourt, showing (evenings and night up to midnight) videos of star performers soon to be coming to Croydon, and by day, a more sober display of white background with black and red letter boards that were and maybe still are on the front of cinemas to announce the films on offer.
It’s clear from all the posts in Inside Croydon over recent months that the works so far have cost a huge amount and that more funding is needed to carry out renewal of the concert hall seating, and other things. I hope that the council invest the necessary, subject to full competitive tendering.
More events, original acts, greater variety, are clearly all great but depend on the public paying their hard-won £s to enjoy a night out at the Fairfield, rather than go up to central London theatreland, South Bank, Barbican, the O2 etc.
It would be interesting to see how sales are of the more expensive seats, but clearly carycb was in a “full house” –twice–which is very good news. I hope that the ones I have booked will also be.