‘Council flats crisis has been heartbreaking, and cruel’

The scandal over the appalling conditions in South Norwood flats rolls on, as the council evacuated some of its tenants into poor conditions – in one case, placing a mother with a two-year-old toddler into what appeared to be a bail hostel. JANE NICHOLL explains how Croydon managed to make a very bad situation even worse

All three blocks of flats at Regina Road have been affected by leaks, damp and mould

For the past two months I have been supporting one of the residents in the Regina Road flats.

I met her when delivering meals and groceries to her flat through South Norwood Community Kitchen. The first time I saw her, she answered the door and she and her two-year-old toddler were in wellies – the floor of their flat was so saturated. It stank of damp and mould and it was freezing. She’d been contacting the council for the past two years, from when the decay started.

She and I went on the offensive, contacting housing officials, Steve Reed MP and South Norwood ward councillors Jane Avis (who has now stood down) and Patsy Cummings.

Patsy didn’t seem happy with me being involved. She would not reply to any of my emails, but repeatedly told the resident that she’d “got it” and for her to tell me there’s no need for me to be involved as yet again (yawn) “she’d got it”.

Until the exposure on ITV News two weeks ago, it seemed that Councillor Cummings had never been inside the block, and she had certainly not spoken to the resident face to face.

After weeks and weeks of conflicting answers in emails from the various council departments about the works that needed doing, at one point they offered the resident a new flat. That turned out to be a “mistake”, as the flat was for a person with disabilities. More than once the young mother was told there were other people worse off than her, as there was a fair amount of gaslighting and guilt-tripping from her landlords,  the council.

What she has been dragged through is heartbreaking, shocking and cruel.

The temporary B&B accommodation in which the council placed at least one of its displaced South Norwood households

Fast forward to the News At Ten report that shocked the nation, and the shit the council had forced its residents to live in had been exposed.

I received a call from the resident early on the morning after the television news had been broadcast. A council official had turned up, banging on her door and thrust into her hand a piece of paper stating “Warning of Enforced Entry”.

The resident was told that she and her two-year-old had to go into temporary bed and breakfast accommodation immediately and she was to start packing. No prior warning, nothing.

When I turned up, the block was swarming with council workers from just about every council department in the borough, having to make themselves look like they cared and showing that they were actually doing something after all this time. Councillors Patsy Cummings and Clive Fraser were there, too, doing some sort of “goodwill doorknock” stuff. Nauseating.

The various people from building works came wandering in and out of her flat – at the time the resident was trying to get her two-year-old to sleep over all the shouting and loud voices and banging doors.

Throughout the day there was stream of conflicting advice and decisions: she does need to pack her belongings; no she doesn’t; work doesn’t need to be done as the fault is in empty flat below; no, it does need to be done after all. On and on it went, with the poor resident’s stress levels getting worse and worse.

The resident was told she could go and stay in a Premier Inn for a few nights which was “very nice”, while permanent accommodation was arranged and she would be viewing a flat the next day.

Hamida Ali and Sarah Jones and their tactless tweet in the middle of the council flats crisis angered residents

Laura and Emma from the Community Kitchen arrived to add to the support for the resident. She was told she had to go to the council housing office to sign the papers to get access to the bedsit. I did ask the housing official if the papers could be brought to the resident. That got a firm “No”.

So off it was for her and her two-year-old to sign the forms, then back to the flat to pack (enough for two to three nights, she was told), and then off to meet the housing person to be let into the “very nice” bedsit.

“Very nice” my arse, and certainly not a Premier Inn. The said bedsit was in a damp, run-down Victorian house, one of nine in the building. Her room had no washbasin, the beds were broken, the place was cold and that night she had her two-year-old had to sleep on the sofa.

The next morning, some sort of warden came round banging on all the residents doors at 8am to prove that they had all spent the night there. Seriously. She asked me: “Is this a bail hostel?”

And so it goes on. Next day when I went with her to pick up some more of her belongings we met council leader Hamida Ali just leaving the flats (Did she even go in? Who knows?).

I couldn’t hold back, so let out a whole load of angry questions at her. We got the same answers as ever – she didn’t know about it, she didn’t know why she didn’t know about it. Deplorable.

My friend, the Regina Road resident, didn’t hold back either, angrily and tearfully telling the councillor the disgusting situation all the residents have been living in.

‘I get it’: Patsy Cummings, here with former council leader Tony Newman, seemed to dismiss tenants’ complaints

Later that week,  she was told she was being moved to another, “better” bedsit. When I called her, she was on her way to see it.

I have referred to this amazingly resilient woman as “The Resident”. I’ve given her anonymity as she is so worn down by the bullying and neglect of Croydon Council that she fears repercussions.

Laura, Emma and I are sickened by what has gone on. I’m angry, really really angry. I have witnessed a wonderful woman being broken by the systemic negligent and inhumane behaviour of the council.

There are many, many people in that block who have not yet been given a voice and had their own concerns listened to. We need to hear them now. No more lengthy enquiries taking place behind closed doors. Enough is enough.

Read more: Croydon shamed over ‘dangerous squalor’ in council flats
Read more: ‘Is it because the council don’t care? Where is their humanity?’
Read more: ‘My family’s hell on earth’: 18 months in a Croydon B&B
Read more: ‘My living nightmare in temporary accommodation’


  • If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, or want to publicise your residents’ association or business, or if you have a local event to promote, please email us with full details at inside.croydon@btinternet.com
  • Inside Croydon is a member of the Independent Community News Network
  • Inside Croydon works together with the Bureau of Investigative Journalism and BBC London News
  • ROTTEN BOROUGH AWARDS: Croydon was named the country’s rottenest borough in 2020 in the annual round-up of civic cock-ups in Private Eye magazine – the fourth successive year that Inside Croydon has been the source for such award-winning nominations
  • Inside Croydon: 3million page views in 2020. Seen by 1.4million unique visitors

About insidecroydon

News, views and analysis about the people of Croydon, their lives and political times in the diverse and most-populated borough in London. Based in Croydon and edited by Steven Downes. To contact us, please email inside.croydon@btinternet.com
This entry was posted in Clive Fraser, Croydon Council, Hamida Ali, Jane Avis, Patsy Cummings, South Norwood, South Norwood Community Kitchen, South Norwood Tourist Board, Tony Newman and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to ‘Council flats crisis has been heartbreaking, and cruel’

  1. krautview says:

    Well done, well said and well written, Jane Nicholl. A for abomonable, B for brutal, C for Croydon Council, D for Disgusting, distressing, disgraceful, degrading ….

  2. miapawz says:

    Jane Nicholl, thank you for supporting this lady and gosh does she need support as she is not getting it from Croydon Council. I am shocked for them. They don’t seem to be ashamed for themselves. Sarah Jones MP is campaigning not helping. Not impressed.

    On Regina Road owers: could they be decent homes if they were MAINTAINED? Have they been broken by inappropriate fitting of cavity insulation, plumbing leaky sprinkers or some kind of alteration that has gone wrong? Where are maintenance teams for these blocks? Have they been neglected so badly they are now mouldy and leaky? why so leaky? what a waste of flats not being looked after by the landlord (Croydon Council).

    Again, how can this be ‘reality’ : Inappropriate B&Bs when this council has brick by brick allegedly building social housing! I see the flats being built on top of plots all over the borough: why are homeless residents not allowed to live in them? Has anyone actually benefited in Croydon from Brick by Brick building any +social+ housing?

  3. Rod Davies says:

    The harrowing account begs a single question. Who in the housing department was in charge of this activity and responsible for coordinating all council actions and managing the communication with the resident?
    It is almost unbelievable that the incident should have evolved as it did.
    It occurs to me that in other local authorities this would result in disciplinary action for the responsible officer.

  4. krautview says:

    Are Nick Davies and Rod Davies related? I think we shoud be told

  5. moyagordon says:

    The ward councillors seem to be good for nothing! This is neglect of duty. Why are things so badly run and how can we change things?

Leave a Reply to Rod Davies Cancel reply