Butler and Scott among those not facing the voters again

WALTER CRONXITE, our political editor, on the high drop-out rate among Croydon’s Labour councillors, bruised and deflated after nearly eight years in charge at the Town Hall

Architect of his own downfall: Paul Scott is not seeking selection to run for the council next year

Paul Scott and Alison Butler, the husband and wife duo who made up half of Tony Newman’s “Gang of Four”, and who ruled over the Labour group and the council with a rod of iron for more than a decade, are among nine councillors from the ruling group at the Town Hall who are not seeking reselection to stand at next May’s local elections.

Together with two sitting councillors who have not survived their party’s internal selection process and the three long-standing councillors who quit earlier this year, that makes more than one-third of the 41 Labour councillors elected since 2018 who won’t be on the ballot papers at the Town Hall elections in seven months’ time.

And the casualty rate could yet be higher still, once the votes are all counted on the morning of May 6, after electors have their say over the administration that bankrupted the borough.

Housing crisis: Alison Butler delivered few council homes and scandal over conditions in Regina Road flats

While there has been speculation previously over who will, and who won’t, seek reselection for the Labour benches, the latest roll call of drop-outs is based on the finalised application forms submitted to party officials.

Other Newman numpties who have decided that they don’t want to face the electorate again next spring, when they risk being given the kind of message that even Inside Croydon would find unacceptable to publish on a family-read website, are Toni Letts, who is standing down after 36 years on the council, and Louisa Woodley, who somehow hung on to cabinet-level jobs throughout Newman’s reign of terror.

Scott, a close mate of Newman, has been a councillor for Woodside ward since 2002. Extraordinarily, while chair of the planning committee from 2014 and then cabinet member for planning and design issues until 2020, he was allowed to go for six years with a special dispensation that meant that he never had to declare any conflicts of interest at council meetings – despite his day job as a director of a firm of architects well-known in the London building trade.

Butler and Scott drove the failed Brick by Brick housing experiment

Butler had been a councillor from 2002 to 2006, and then for Bensham Manor ward since 2007.

Butler was seen by Katharine Street regulars as the real power behind the throne, dictating to Newman what directions to take. A former constituency aide to Croydon North MP Malcolm Wicks, Butler’s own parliamentary ambitions were thwarted when she lost the Croydon Central selection in 2014 to Sarah Jones, as some party members took a rare opportunity to settle old scores.

After Labour won control of the Town Hall in 2014, as well as deputy leader of the council, Butler was also cabinet member for housing, and as a consequence was at the centre of three of the massive scandals that dragged the council into bankruptcy and disrepute.

Extraordinarily, considering Newman and the fourth member of the “gang”, Simon Hall, remain suspended by the Labour Party for their part in the council’s financial collapse, Butler appears to have escaped without sanction.

It was on Butler’s watch that the “appalling” conditions in council flats in South Norwood were allowed to fester and deteriorate to the point that Croydon became headline news on News at Ten – with Butler ducking the on-camera ignominy and shame because she had been sacked four months earlier because of the financial disaster she had wrought at the Town Hall.

Going: Toni Letts

It was Butler who boasted to Labour Party Conference about how Brick by Brick would solve the borough’s housing crisis, yet in six years delivered only a handful of new council homes and a mountain of debt. And it was Butler who handed the contract for the refurbishment of the Fairfield Halls to Brick by Brick, creating a £70million “fiasco” and leaving bills that will have to be paid by generations of Croydon residents to come.

And with her husband in charge of the planning committee, there were constant questions about propriety, as Scott bullied and cajoled his committee into granting permission to every Brick by Brick scheme that came before them, with councillors maintaining that he broke planning law to do so.

Today, when asked for a comment about Butler and Scott and their 20-year spell as Croydon councillors, another Katharine Street figure paused. For almost a minute. And then said, “You can quote me on that.”

Councillors (from left) Robert Canning, Andrew Pelling and Joy Prince: two have chosen not to stand again in 2022

While Scott, Butler, Letts and Woodley may not be much missed, four others who have decided to stand down might be more fondly remembered for their work for their residents.

Joy Prince and Robert Canning, who in 2014 helped to win Waddon from the Conservatives, making it the only ward in Croydon South to be held by Labour, might be timing their departures in anticipation of the likely backlash at the polls next May.

Both were well regarded locally and at the Town Hall, with Canning notably being a lone Labour voice capable of blocking Brick by Brick blocks of flats on his patch, and also being the only Labour councillor in October 2020 not to back Newman and Hall in a vote of confidence.

Thornton Heath councillor Pat Clouder is standing down after 24 years, mostly spent as a backbencher and working hard across a range of roles and council committees.

Going: Pat Clouder

Stephen Mann joined the council in 2014 when still in his early 20s, first for Ashburton ward, then from 2018 for Crystal Palace and Upper Norwood. Over the years, under Newman’s leadership, Town Hall observers could see the enthusiasm ebbing away,  being replaced by disillusionment. Sources in the local party suggest that the conduct of one of his ward colleagues was a deciding factor.

Jamie Audsley and Mary Croos are two more sitting councillors who, as previously reported, have not, as yet, been approved by the Labour Party to be considered for reselection in 2022 under what has been criticised as “a flawed and corrupt” process.

But the final councillor to choose not to stand again is one who was also at the centre of another Croydon Labour controversy just two years ago.

Caragh Skipper was not selected by Fairfield Labour members to fight the ward byelection  in November 2019, but in a fix arranged by local party officials, her name was put forward as the candidate for the safe Labour ward ahead of the democratically chosen Jose Joseph.

Going: Caragh Skipper (right) was not selected for Fairfield, but got support from Chris Clark and Tony Newman (left)

An internal Labour report, leaked to Inside Croydon, confirmed that the selection was rigged, but failed to make any recommendations of disciplinary action against Jack Buck, the party employee and local election agent whose conduct did so much to oust Joseph and install Skipper.

All that intrigue, trouble and strife appears, now, to have been for very little: Skipper’s skipping off after a brief dalliance at serving the public.

According to a senior source in the Croydon Labour group, Skipper’s decision is “not for political reasons”.

Read more: Brick by Brick part of a perfect storm that bankrupted Croydon
Read more: Council to pick up £69.2m costs of failed Fairfield Halls refurb
Read more: Labour councillor was given ‘no real reason’ for deselection
Read more: Leader apologises for six years of misrule
Read more: ‘Tony Newman always has been a coward’


  • If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, or want to publicise your residents’ association or business, or if you have a local event to promote, please email us with full details at inside.croydon@btinternet.com
  • Inside Croydon is a member of the Independent Community News Network
  • Inside Croydon works together with the Bureau of Investigative Journalism, as well as BBC London News and ITV London
  • ROTTEN BOROUGH AWARDS: Croydon was named the country’s rottenest borough in 2020 in the annual round-up of civic cock-ups in Private Eye magazine – the fourth successive year that Inside Croydon has been the source for such award-winning nominations
  • Inside Croydon: 3million page views in 2020. Seen by 1.4million unique visitors

About insidecroydon

News, views and analysis about the people of Croydon, their lives and political times in the diverse and most-populated borough in London. Based in Croydon and edited by Steven Downes. To contact us, please email inside.croydon@btinternet.com
This entry was posted in 2022 council elections, Alison Butler, Brick by Brick, Caragh Skipper, Fairfield, Fairfield Halls, Housing, Jamie Audsley, Jose Joseph, Joy Prince, Louisa Woodley, Mary Croos, Paul Scott, Robert Canning, Selhurst, Stephen Mann, Toni Letts, Tony Newman, Waddon, Woodside and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Butler and Scott among those not facing the voters again

  1. Geoff James says:

    It would be great if there was more openness and transparency so that the gang-of-four mentioned can be assessed against the yardstick of “criminal negligence”? May be that can be the principle focus of the manifestos next May for the parties (and hopefully the Elected Mayor). Clearly, under the current regime, that is only focused on its own self-interest, we are not getting anywhere.

    There is much-delayed independent report that was provided to the Council back in February. There have been various delays to the public release, with the last being a promise to release it last month (September).

    This report has not (yet) materialised? – me thinks it is too toxic to release before today’s referendum (I wonder why?). May be will be release in the next couple of weeks so that the maximum amount of time can pass before the elections in May. – now that would be a complete ocus on self-interest!!

  2. CentralCroydon says:

    And good bloody riddance to Scott and Butler. Croydon would be in a much better place if they had never been elected.

  3. At last some good news. Hurrah , hurrah, Hurray!!!! Not a moment too soon.

  4. What an utter shambles. Do readers remember Paul Scott arranging for muppet Toni Letts to replace him as chair of the planning committee in order to allow Tony Newman to pay Scott a load more expenses? Meanwhile Scott told Letts what to do on planning.

    It’s milking and then playing the system, all to his financial advantage.

    Goodbye, Scott.

    Croydon is immeasurably better off without you.

  5. Sally says:

    Finally some good news for Croydon. I really hope there is a full investigation – criminal if necessary – into these councillors.

Leave a Reply to Sally Cancel reply