“Is it murder or manslaughter?”
Summing up: the murder case judge Mrs Justice Cheema-Grubb
That was the stark question that the defence barrister in the murder trial of New Addington teen Hassan Sentamu put to the jury at the Old Bailey this morning, as he concluded his closing statement before the summing up of judge Mrs Justice Cheema-Grubb.
Pavlos Panayi KC described Sentamu’s victim Elianne Andam as a “poor, poor girl”, while also saying she was one of his client’s “tormentors”.
Panayi had begun his closing statement on Friday, and he spent another hour this morning leading the jury in Court No15 through the evidence and testimonies as his client would prefer the jurors to interpret them, about the events that led to the tragic killing of 15-year-old schoolgirl Andam on Wellesley Road, outside the Whitgift Centre, on a September morning in 2023.
Sentamu had opted against taking the witness stand to give evidence in his defence, or be cross-examined.
Evidence presented on behalf of Sentamu claimed that his autism spectrum disorder caused him to lose control during the meeting to exchange belongings with his ex-girlfriend, who was Andam’s friend.
Sentamu, 18, has admitted manslaughter, but denies murder on the basis of diminished responsibility.
On Friday, the prosecutor, Alex Chalk KC, had told the court that Sentamu had “exacted vengeance on a young girl clearly running away from him and posing no threat”.
Moment of arrest: Hassan Sentamu denies murdering 15-year-old Elianne Andam outside the Whitgift Centre in September 2023
Much of defence lawyer Panayi’s closing statement focused much on whether the stabbing of Andam had been premeditated.
He sought to diminish the “I can’t let this slide bro” comment that his client had made in a text message to a friend the day before the killing, a comment described by the prosecution as, “The most chilling words in this trial.”
Panayi told the court today that Elianne Andam running, laughing and grabbing the bag with her friend’s possessions, including her teddy bear, was “the trigger”. He suggested that Sentamu may have intended to attend the meeting and not hand over his former girlfriend’s things.
“If he had not taken the knife, his explosion of anger would have manifested in another way,” Panayi suggested to the jury, before reminding jurors of the love letters that were in the bag and describing Andam as one of Sentamu’s “tormentors”.
Panayi also sought to dismiss the significance of Sentamu’s decision to wear a mask and gloves to the meeting. “He may have worn them out to look tough,” he said.
“Is there a sensible case, the gloves and mask are evidence of premeditation? Or is it just a soundbyte? Maybe a bit tabloid?”
He went on to suggest that Sentamu’s taking the knife to the meeting was “an afterthought”.
Murdered in the street: Elianne Andam
Later, referring to the seizing of the bag by Andam: “Was that last event like pulling the pin on a hand grenade? Poor, poor girl. It was not her fault. It was his fault. I would say he has admitted that.”
On the psychiatric evidence, Panayi told the jury: “You have a difficult job. You are going to have to do a difficult job evaluating two equally eminent psychiatrists, who both respect each other, who both reached two different conclusions.
“You are more than entitled to reject anyone else’s factual analysis.
“Conduct Disorder: Is it a red herring?”
- If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, or want to publicise your residents’ association or business, or if you have a local event to promote, please email us with full details at inside.croydon@btinternet.com
As featured on Google News Showcase
- Our comments section on every report provides all readers with an immediate “right of reply” on all our content. Our comments policy can be read by clicking here
Inside Croydon is a member of the Independent Community News Network
