Croydon Ad cleared of any offence in teen stabbing report

Spotted this interesting report on the journalism trade website, Press Gazette, earlier this week. The Croydon Advertiser‘s former editor, Ian Carter, has been cleared of any offence over a report in the paper in September 2008 about a teenager involved in a Youth Court case.

The Advertiser ran an interview with a teen who’d been victim of a stabbing, and who had given evidence in the Youth Court. Access to Youth Court proceedings for the public, and the media, are tightly controlled. The CPS argued that the Advertiser story broke reporting restrictions that banned identification of the youth.

The judge, Suzanne Byrne, dismissed the CPS’s case quite abruptly, saying: “I find that this article was not one to which section 49 of the act relates as it is not a report of the proceedings in the Youth Court.” You can read the rest of the judge’s ruling in the PG story.

A couple of points of interest.

  • Great to see the CPS covering itself in glory in the pursuit of some real criminal activity.
  • While the paper’s editor obviously takes ultimate responsibility for anything that appears in his newspaper, it seems a little odd that the PG report makes no mention of the reporter who got the interview, nor the Advertiser news editor of the time who cleared the piece for publication. Inside Croydon is aware that at least two of those concerned in the publication of the story are no longer working in Croydon.
  • Carter was represented legally by the same lawyers who originally checked the article prior to publication. The CPS has been ordered to meet all of Carter’s and the Advertiser‘s legal costs. Had the paper lost, these costs would have been met by its legal insurance. Inside Croydon understands that the Croydon Advertiser, in another brilliant piece of cost-cutting, no longer has a legal insurance policy.

Ian Carter cleared over teen stabbing interview – Journalism news and jobs for journalists – Press Gazette.

About insidecroydon

News, views and analysis about the people of Croydon, their lives and political times in the diverse and most-populated borough in London. Based in Croydon and edited by Steven Downes. To contact us, please email
This entry was posted in Local media. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Croydon Ad cleared of any offence in teen stabbing report

  1. jowadsworth says:

    A couple of points of clarification. I assume that when you refer to the Advertiser news editor of the time, you are referring to me. I had no involvement in this story at all.

    You also imply that the reason two people involved in the story are no longer working in Croydon might be something to do with this story. Nobody’s departure from the Advertiser had any connection with this story.

    If you don’t publish this comment, as you usually don’t publish comments from me, I would appreciate your rewording your post to clarify these points.

  2. Hmmm.

    Croydon Advertiser News Editor has ‘no involvement in news story whatsoever’ shock!

    “Assume”? Dangerous.

    “Imply”? Not at all. Can’t control what you may infer from a statement of fact.

Leave a Reply