Cummings wins by-election as Labour increase vote share

WALTER CRONXITE on the very predictable outcome of yesterday’s council vote

Elected: Jeremy Corbyn supporter Patsy Cummings

And so, as no one ever doubted, it is now Councillor Patsy Cummings, following the by-election in the safe Labour ward of South Norwood yesterday.

That restores Labour’s tally at Croydon Town Hall to 39 councillors (with one banished permanently on the naughty step), to the Tories’ 30, though that will surely change next May, when the local elections determine the composition of the council for the next four years.

For the record (and hey, we’re not complaining, but why is Croydon Council under returning officer Jo Negrini incapable of posting a proper, verified election result on its website once it has the figures? It’s not much to ask, but democracy demands no less), Cummings polled 1,671 votes, or 59 per cent of the vote on a day of modest turn-out. Labour’s share of the vote was up 7.9 per cent on equivalent polling in the same ward in 2014.

The Conservative candidate, one of Croydon Tories’ “B-listers”, got 16.8 per cent (down 3.4 per cent). That was not the sort of result upon which the Tories can begin to plot for control of the Town Hall next May.

In fact, the FibDems were very close behind the Tories, on 13.7 per cent (up 6.7 per cent).

The Greens – the only party that can beat Labour, according to their own skewed graphics – dropped to fourth on 7.7 per cent (down 3.3 per cent).

And fewer than 100 people turned out to vote for UKIP.

The by-election had been called after Labour’s Kathy Bee took a politically restricted Civil Service job that prevents her from being a councillor.

Can anything be read into yesterday’s result ahead of next May’s Town Hall elections? Probably not.

Tony Newman makes sure he’s to the fore in a group which also includes Alison Butler and Paul Scott to acclaim Patsy Cummings’ ward by-election win in South Norwood last night. Try to spot Clive Fraser, the candidate’s agent who actually did some work on the campaign

Compared with the two other by-elections staged during this council term, in Selhurst and West Thornton, both similarly safe Labour wards in the north of the borough, the vote shares and the finishing orders are consistent.

The LibDems did noticeably better in South Norwood than they have been performing in this borough since 2010 (are people beginning to forget what Nick Clegg connived to do to the country with the Tories?), and UKIP are consigned to the rubbish bin of history as the irrelevance with a nasty streak that every sensible person always knew that they were.

Within Croydon’s Labour group, though, the election of Cummings may have greater significance.

All Labour’s candidates in the by-elections since 2015 have been of Afro-Caribbean heritage, Cummings the only woman of the three. That at least attempts to better reflect the diversity of the borough’s residents which – given the Tories’ stubborn refusal even to consider gender balance in their candidate selections for 2018 – can only make Croydon Conservatives look even more out of step with the communities that they claim to wish to serve.

Jeremy Corbyn arriving in Croydon with his aide, Patsy Cummings (grey shirt) at his side. Photo: GRANT MELTON

In Cummings, too, the Labour group in Croydon is beginning to better reflect the mood of the vast majority of the party’s membership.

Cummings worked in Jeremy Corbyn’s office during this summer’s General Election, although last year she was ousted as chair of the Croydon North Constituency Labour Party by a candidate deemed to be more acceptable to Progress MP Steve Reed OBE.

Reed and his Blairite buddy on the council, Tony Newman, ensured that they were to the fore in canvassing selfies in the last days of a subdued “election campaign” in South Norwood. They posed together in Homelands Drive, apparently an irony-free zone so close to where the council wants to overdevelop Auckland Rise through the increasingly loathed Brick by Brick profiteering development company.

And last night Newman and two of his Gang of Four, Alison Butler and her husband, Paul Scott, turned up to make sure that they were in the Town Hall for the vote announcement, the council leader getting himself to the front of the picture, as if to take credit for the outcome. As a result, pushed into the background of the picture was another party member, Clive Fraser. As Cummings’ election agent, it had been Fraser who had done much of the work for the election, backed with the help of dozens of activists from Momentum.

The picture line-up was apt as a metaphor for Newman and his clique’s control-freak handling of the Labour group on the council, and the party in Croydon.

But after the mauling Newman has received in the past week in the London-wide media over the council’s children’s services crisis, it may be a mode of behaviour that they may not be able to continue to practice for much longer.

  • Inside Croydon is a member of the Independent Community News Network
  • Inside Croydon is the borough’s only independent news source, and still based in the heart of Croydon
  • In the five months from April to August 2017, Inside Croydon generated more than 500,000 page views
  • If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, a residents’ or business association or a local event to publicise, please email us with full details at

About insidecroydon

News, views and analysis about the people of Croydon, their lives and political times in the diverse and most-populated borough in London. Based in Croydon and edited by Steven Downes. To contact us, please email
This entry was posted in Clive Fraser, Patsy Cummings, South Norwood, Tony Newman and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Cummings wins by-election as Labour increase vote share

  1. Nick Mattey says:

    During the General Election the Greens were urging voters to vote for the Liberal Democrats except in Brighton Pavilion home of Caroline Lucas . It seems that the message has got through and Green Voters are now voting Liberal Democrat.

Leave a Reply