STEVEN DOWNES on reactions and responses to the not-so-magnificent seven’s resignation from the Labour Party
The bitter, decade-long personal, political feud between Chuka Umunna and Steve Reed OBE may have played a significant factor in the former vice-chair of Progress today stating determinedly that he would be remaining a Labour member and not joining the seven splitters who announced their resignation from the party this morning.
Back in 2009, Reed, as leader of Lambeth Council, had expected to be selected as the prospective Labour candidate for his then home constituency of Streatham. But Umunna came along with a more radical, left-wing prospectus than his Blairite rival, and won over local party members who had tired of the party’s dalliance with neo-liberalism.
Reed had to cool his heels until 2012, and the death of Croydon North MP Malcolm Wicks, before he could progress his own political ambitions and get elected to parliament in another safe Labour seat.
Today, Umunna severed his links with Labour as he and six Remain-supporting MP colleagues staged a press conference in order to slate their erstwhile party leader Jeremy Corbyn while announcing that they will form an independent group in parliament.
They said they were disgusted by the party’s handling of anti-semitism and its Brexit policy. Many observers assessed that they have opted for political oblivion, but that they might do enough to split the left to ensure Tory governments for many years to come, just as happened with the SDP in the 1980s.
The MPs are:
- Umunna, the former shadow business secretary;
- Luciana Berger, MP for Liverpool Wavertree and former shadow minister for mental health;
- Gavin Shuker, MP for Luton South and former shadow international development minister;
- Angela Smith, MP for Penistone and Stocksbridge and former shadow deputy leader of the House of Commons;
- Chris Leslie, MP Nottingham East and former shadow chancellor;
- Mike Gapes, MP for Ilford South and former chair of the foreign affairs select committee; and
- Ann Coffey, MP for Stockport and former parliamentary private secretary to Alistair Darling when he was chancellor of the exchequer.
None of the seven splitters, when asked, said that they would be resigning from parliament to prompt a by-election in their constituencies because, they claimed, in 2017 when they were elected when standing on Labour’s “For the Many, Not the Few”, the electorate chose them personally, and they did not owe their positions to any party policies.
Both Umunna and Berger have recently been threatened with deselection by their CLPs, which is surely only a coincidence.
Such a split has been predicted almost since Corbyn was elected Labour leader in 2015, and there had been rumours of a centrist party launch since the New Year. It had been expected that some People’s Vote-supporting Tories – the likes of Anna Soubry and Sarah Wollaston – would align themselves with the group, but in the event, that did not happen.
Among the first to reject the independent group’s premise was Reed, a leading figure from the Blairite wing of the Labour Party and, indeed, one of the plotters who tried to oust Corbyn in the “chicken coup” of 2016.
This time, Reed – himself a People’s Vote supporter – was having no truck with the undermining of the party.
On Twitter, Reed wrote, “I’m watching the seven MPs quitting the party on TV and I’m more convinced than ever that Labour, the greatest force for social change this country’s ever known, can lead Britain forward if we now come together as a party to shape the future.”
Shortly after, Reed added this: “I’ve been a member of the Labour Party for 40 years this year, and I’m looking forward to being a member for the next 40 years.”
The remark prompted one Katharine Street observer to comment, “He doesn’t look old enough.”
It was significant that the Twitter feed of Reed’s constituency Labour Party soon after put out a link to a code of conduct for its members when using social media, a warning for them not to direct anger or abuse at Umunna’s not-so-magnificent seven.
That appeal for social media calm was also reflected in the comments of shadow foreign secretary Emily Thornberry: “If you criticise or abuse these individuals, if you impugn their motives, and if you encourage any others to join them, you are helping them not hurting them, because you are taking your eyes off the prize and allowing our movement to be distracted and divided, which is exactly what they want.
“The only thing that anyone should do in response to the action of these MPs today is to respectfully and politely ask them a simple question: Do they intend to put up candidates in Labour-Tory marginals, and split the Labour vote?”
Indeed, Thornberry’s warning may need to be heeded in south London, where a battle to unseat Umunna at the polls could see campaign resources – and boots on the ground – diverted from Sarah Jones’s marginal Croydon Central seat to Streatham.
But Thornberry’s wise counsel seemed to be ignored by Jack Buck, Croydon Labour’s paid organiser, who during office hours was busy on his personal Twitter account sending out a series of less-than-conciliatory messages.
“If any Labour MP quits now, just as the Tory party are in the midst of their biggest crisis in a hundred years, the resulting chaos will be on them and nobody else,” Buck first wrote.
Buck, who is an elected councillor in Southwark, then added, “Being elected at any level means acting responsibly and in the interests of others not yourself.”
Buck’s next message read: “Also, prediction. If Labour MPs split off it will be a matter of days/weeks before Theresa May calls an election to try and save herself. This will be supposedly people with Labour values saving a Conservative prime minister.”
And then, possibly with an eye on the imminent vacancy for a Labour Party candidate in Streatham, Buck said: “The case for open, transparent and mandatory re-selection of Labour parliamentary candidates just got made better than any grassroots campaign ever could.”
Other London Labour figures, including many who have worked in the Commons with the splitters, tended to take a more conciliatory tone.
Sadiq Khan, the Mayor of London, said it is a “desperately sad day” for Labour, but that he would being sticking with the party. “These seven MPs are all friends of mine. I served alongside them in parliament,” he wrote.
“I agree that the only way through the mess of Brexit is to give the public the final say, and that the Labour Party needs to do much more to root out the evil of anti-semitism.
“However, history clearly shows that the only way to get real change in our society – whether fighting for a public vote, tackling inequality, or ending austerity – is within the Labour Party. When the Labour Party splits it only leads to one outcome – a Tory government – and that means a hard Tory Brexit.”
None of the seven feel at ease with many of the positions taken by the Corbyn-led Labour Party, although all seven stood on the Labour manifesto at the General Election little more than 20 months ago.
“They’re not so much champagne socialists,” one observer said, “but with Chuka in charge, they’re Savile Row socialists.”
Today, Laura Parker, the national co-ordinator of Momentum, the Corbyn-supporting group of grassroots members, said, “Labour’s common sense socialism has widespread support amongst the public, has inspired hundreds of thousands to join the party and caused the most spectacular electoral comeback in British history.
“Labour now has a plan to rebuild Britain. These MPs want to take us back to the politics of the past with a back-to-the-Blair-years programme of privatisation, tax cuts for the rich and deregulation of the banks.
“They offer no concrete solutions, no new ideas and have no support amongst the public.”
Today of all days, Berger, Umunna, Leslie and their colleagues might do well to remind themselves of a bit of elementary Marxism.
For if Umunna’s group is to be the SDP for our age, then the threat of another 10 years of Tory government might well be their poisoned legacy.
And as Karl Marx said, “History repeats itself, first as tragedy, second as farce.”
- Please support Inside Croydon’s award-winning, news-breaking local journalism. It’s just £4 per month, and you qualify for special discounts and offers. Click here to sign-up as a donor
- Inside Croydon is a member of the Independent Community News Network
- Inside Croydon works together with the Bureau of Investigative Journalism and BBC London News
- Inside Croydon named Journalist of the Year at 2018 Anna Kennedy Online Autism Heroes Awards
- ROTTEN BOROUGH AWARDS: For two consecutive years, 2017 and 2018, Inside Croydon has been the source for two award-winning nominations in Private Eye magazine’s annual celebration of civic cock-ups
- In 2018, Inside Croydon had 1.6million pages viewed by more than half a million unique visitors
- If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, or what to publicise your residents’ association or business, or if you have a local event to promote, please email us with full details at firstname.lastname@example.org