They cost us £6m. Are our councillors really up to the job?

CROYDON COMMENTARY: How well do you know your local councillor? Are they actually up to the job? Do they even have a job?
SEBASTIAN TILLINGER has been checking through the public declarations

Are our councillors equipped to keep a check on what goes on in the council offices?

There are about 20,000 local councillors in Britain. On Croydon Council, there are 70 of these “democratically-elected local representatives” serving 28 wards. If you’re taking your role as a councillor seriously (not all do), it’s probably hard work. And for some, it’s the only work they do.

A good councillor is expected to balance the needs of his or her local area, residents and voters, community groups, local businesses, and their political party and the council itself.

The reality is often that many councillors put the interests of their political party or their personal interests first. That’s what tends to make a poor councillor. Local council elections routinely enjoy the very worst turnouts: often less than 1 in 3 people who could vote for a local councillor actually do so.

This voter apathy, a belief that nothing will change, and disillusionment with national and local politics, might be said to be reflected in the type of councillors who are drawn to serve us. I look at my local councillors and I feel despondent.

They don’t really represent what I think. They’re slow off the mark, they have no fire in their bellies. A case in point is the planning committee that I sat through the other evening. In these covid-19 times of “virtual” meetings, it was like watching an episode of Gogglebox, but with fewer laughs.

The First Past The Post electoral system fails winners and losers alike. We need proportional representation at local and national level now.

We need an electoral system that attracts high-calibre candidates – candidates that are fit for purpose, are active in and out of the council, and who can bring their professional experience from their day jobs to the role, a sharing of experience and knowledge.

When these councillors engage with private and public organisations outside the borough they should be participating with understanding on a level footing. Less of the bluff and bravado we see from the current council leader when he deals with outside development investors.

Tony Newman: pays himself £56,000 per year, but hasn’t had a proper job for years

We need our councillors to be both local and actively engaged with our communities, while outside the council they should be professionally engaged with the real world – in business, commerce, culture, whatever.

All over Europe, it’s seen as an accolade and honour to serve on your council and it’s often only bestowed after you have established your credentials professionally. Barcelona’s councillors are made up of businessmen, academics, professionals, leaders of non-governmental organisations, and well-known and established community leaders – people who are at the top of their games in their own lives before they seek to serve their local communities.

Based on the declarations that have been made publicly available on the council’s website, in Croydon, half of the council cabinet is unemployed or not in paid work.

Most of the remainder of the cabinet work for other local authorities or Transport for London. This may explain why council leader Tony Newman’s allowances handouts are so sought after and how he maintains his grip on power. Between them, Croydon’s 70 councillors, red and blue, from 2018 to 2022 (the next local elections), will have shared £6million of public money in “special responsibility allowances”.

Of those 70 elected councillors, by far the largest number – 22 – are unemployed or not in paid work. Eleven councillors work for other local authorities or are civil servants, eight work for charities, five of them work for their political parties, four work for TfL, eight are retired and only 12 appear to hold down jobs outside the public sector, in the professions or commerce sector. Is this really representative of a cross-section of Croydon society?


Perhaps it is because the local councillor role attracts a certain type of individual?

I think the calibre of local councillors and the knowledge and experience they bring to this role plays a large part in the apathy we see at local government level in Croydon today.

Unless we can break this, and begin to learn from the Barcelona model, local government in Croydon is going to be even more disconnected, marginalising and failing to serve its communities or, importantly, unable to engage with the outside world on our behalf.

About insidecroydon

News, views and analysis about the people of Croydon, their lives and political times in the diverse and most-populated borough in London. Based in Croydon and edited by Steven Downes. To contact us, please email
This entry was posted in Croydon Council, Tony Newman and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to They cost us £6m. Are our councillors really up to the job?

  1. whitgiftavenue says:

    Although I’m happy with my local councillors, this piece does raise valid questions about the stagnant pool we draw them from.

    Party affiliations do seem to be placed above representing the needs of the community and we can see the effects of the political patronage which goes with this. Yes, there have been recent examples of councillors responding to local concerns over Brick by Brick development proposals, but these have been few and far between and not particularly energetic.

    I don’t have a problem with councillors receiving reasonable allowances.

    However, I do have a big problem with the idea that they can in any way be a substitute for qualified and experienced local authority officers. The decades long ‘cull’ of these officers, with their skills and local knowledge, has resulted in unqualified, elected portfolio-holders taking the lead in vital areas of service provision.

    Sadly, the vast majority of them are just not up to the job. The officers supporting them also seem to lack a civic-service ethos and are drawn from a similarly shallow pool of talent.

    It’s a combination of mediocrity which has led to the likes of Capita having a field day at the expense of communities across the country.

  2. Tim Weller says:

    Excellent, perceptive comments here. I have found my local councillors and MP to be apathetic, unable to be independent of mind and spirit and, to be fit only as lobby fodder. They all toe the party line, fail to think for themselves and, too readily rubber-stamp whatever the officers want. I very rarely get a reply from a councillor by either email or text or phone. Apathy, acquiescence and negligence are the norm. My MP, James Morris Esq is just not bothered about a single one of my concerns, so does nothing. He has deigned to see me, precisely twice in the ten years he has been my MP.

  3. Lewis White says:

    My experience of writing to MPs and Councillors over the years, to MPs in Surrey where I lived before moving into Croydon, and our current Croydon South MP Chris Philp, and his predecessor Richard Ottaway, and my contacts with councillors and cabinet members in Croydon, both Labour and Conservative, have been with few exceptions good and productive. I have raised concerns and have been listened to. More than that, some suggestions I have made have been taken into consideration by decision-makers.

    As with any group of people, there are a lot of Councillors (in all the political parties) who do a lot, and those who don’t do much. There are those who care about things, and those who don’t.

    For me, if the people have elected them, a degree of respect should be afforded unless their conduct and track record shows them to not be worthy of it.

    At the end of the day, Councillors need to represent the needs of all of the borough, and listen to the concerns of their constituents, what ever the latters’ political colours.
    Any councillor who fails to do this is not worthy of respect.

Leave a Reply