There must be an election coming, as the LibDems in Sutton finally wake up to the ‘environmental disaster’ that they have inflicted on Beddington, and Croydon, as our investigations editor, CARL SHILTON, reports
Polluting plume: Viridor’s Beddington incinerator broke its licence limits 916 between 2022 and 2024
Twelve years too late, Sutton’s FibDems have finally admitted that the toxic pollution coming out of the chimneys of the Viridor incinerator at Beddington just might not be an altogether good thing for the people they are supposed to represent.
Sutton’s Liberal Democrat leadership has complained to the Environment Agency that repeat environmental offenders Viridor should be denied permission to burn even more rubbish at their Beddington plant.
After more than a decade of dodgy deals on planning and official cover-ups by the LibDem-controlled council, they have written to Steve Reed, the environment secretary, and to the Environment Agency to say that the Viridor should finally be placed under proper checks and controls, after it was revealed that the £1billion waste-burning facility had broken the terms of its licence nearly a thousand times in just 18 months.
Barry “Basher” Lewis, the Sutton Council leader, last week whizzed off a letter to the CEO of what he called “Virador” (you’d think that by now, after all Viridor’s generous donations to LibDem-supported causes and the millions of pounds paid in business rates, Lewis and his mates might at least know how to spell the company name).
In his note to Pierre Dorel, Viridor’s managing director, Lewis said: “For far too long, Viridor has forgotten the wider community in Beddington, demonstrating little desire to educate or communicate with residents about the facility’s operations, site management and critical operational issues.
“This report must result in a significant change in your approach in order to restore the public trust locally.”
But Lewis and his lackey, Christopher Woolmer, the LibDems’ lead councillor on environment, have been strongly criticised for their “total grovelling obsequiousness” to Viridor by an opposition councillor over what they describe as “the latest environmental disaster inflicted on the borough”.
In truth, it is an environmental disaster for Croydon, as well. Parts of Croydon sit downwind of the pollution plumes from Beddington, and infant mortality rates have increased since the Viridor plant came into full operation.
According to a report from the Environment Agency, between September 2022 and March 2024, there were 916 occasions unreported when the site exceeded its daily emissions limits for the amount of Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) being released into the south London atmosphere. This 916 was in addition to 12 other occasions when Viridor broke the terms of their licence.
Blaming someone else: LibDem council leader Barry ‘Basher’ Lewis
The agency has also admitted that the Beddington incinerator’s emissions, compiled by Viridor, have been incorrectly measured for a number of years, due to a errors in calibrating the incinerator’s air quality monitor (a pretty essential bit of kit for an incinerator, you might think).
The EA has downgraded Viridor’s compliance rating from A to E.
Yet the agency is still actively considering an application to amend Viridor’s licence to allow the company to burn even more rubbish at the plant, which trucks in lorry-loads of other people’s shit from across south-east England.
Sutton’s senior LibDem councillors have been accused of a lack of transparency, and of trying to block efforts of other councillors to keep a check on Viridor’s polluting plumes. Dave Tchil, one of Sutton’s two Labour councillors, accuses the LibDem administration of “[washing] their hands of the responsibility and [acting] like it’s others’ problem”.
Tchil says that the council’s senior staff and LibDem councillors have worked to block his efforts to investigate serious incidents at the plant, “such as the fire on site, the malfunction of the chamber, the noise pollution incident and the numerous complaints about smell and pollution from the stack, all of which seem to have been ignored or not pursued”.
Tchil wrote to residents in his Hackbridge ward: “The council and administration must not be let off the hook for their subservience and disregard for our community.”
Blocked complaints: Labour councillor Dave Tchil says he has been ignored when he has raised multiple issues with the incinerator
And in a letter to Spencer Palmer, the council’s strategic director of environment, as well as to Lewis and Woolmer, Tchil said: “Too often, complaints are logged, minimal information is shared, and it becomes business as usual.”
Tchil calls Lewis’s letters of complaint to the EA and Reed “a hollow gesture”. “This very council and LibDem administration actively campaigned for the incinerator, granted its planning permission and defended its operation.
“The local elections are approaching, and this letter has the appearance of a last-minute attempt by the LibDem administration to distance themselves from this issue.”
According to Lewis and Woolmer in their emails to Reed and the EA, the volume of emissions does not breach air quality standards, and they cite the UK Health Security Agency as suggesting that the emissions are unlikely to have caused harm to human health or the environment. Other experts, however, argue that NOx has no safe threshold before harm to people’s health can occur.
In their letter, Lewis and Woolmer write: “However, for our residents who live in the area, this news will still be deeply troubling.”
The LibDems granted planning permission for the facility in 2013, even contesting a Judicial Review over its process in the High Court in 2014.
‘Total grovelling obsequiousness’: opposition councillors have been unimpressed by Basher Lewis’s belated realisation that Viridor are his borough’s biggest polluters
Viridor’s managing director at the time of the planning application was a life-long chum of a senior Sutton LibDem councillor, who sat on the planning committee but never declared any conflict of interest.
Now, Lewis and Woolmer complain: “What is also concerning is the lack of proper monitoring and scrutiny by the EA of the data they received from Viridor. In order for these sites to run as required, it is important that our residents have confidence in the ability of agencies like yours to provide the highest levels of regulation.
“The report’s findings only contribute to the erosion of that trust.
“Despite the report, and the downgrading of Viridor’s compliance rating from A to E, we are aware that the EA is still considering approving plans for Viridor to treat more waste at the Beddington site.
“The council has opposed any increases and we are astonished that the EA is still even considering this. This is unequivocally the wrong decision.”
Consistent: councillor Nick Mattey
Having acceded to pretty much every request from Viridor since 2012, Sutton’s LibDems now demand of the Environment Agency that they “hold Viridor to account” and take “strong and appropriate enforcement action against Viridor”.
And rather than take Viridor’s own monitoring at face value, they have belatedly decided that independent monitoring of the site is required and more frequent EA inspections are necessary.
Nick Mattey, the Beddington independent councillor who has consistently and persistently exposed Viridor’s polluting practices and the money-grabbing hypocrisy of local Liberal Democrats, described Lewis’s letter as “pathetically weak”.
Mattey said: “It could not even be regarded as a mild rebuke — the subtext is simply that ‘we want to stay friends, and we have an election coming up next year’.”
Mattey says that the EA report exposes yet more shortcomings in the way Viridor have been measuring, and underreporting, their emissions. “There are no figures provided about how much additional NOx was released into the atmosphere.
“This omission goes to the heart of the matter: without transparency on the actual scale of excess pollution, residents are left in the dark while the council bends over backwards to protect Viridor.”
Read more: Infant death rates were up by 233% after incinerator fired up
Read more: Now ‘Basher’ Lewis knocks out debate on polluting incinerator
Read more: Viridor incinerator fined for multiple pollution permit breaches
Read more: Viridor’s charge sheet: incinerator operator’s eco-vandalism
Read more: After a decade of delay, Sutton condemns Viridor. Sort of
- There’s a running total of the breaches by Viridor’s Beddington incinerator at http://www.merton.tv/incinerator-breaches/
PAID ADS: To advertise your services or products to our 10,000 weekday visitors to the site, as featured on Google News Showcase, email us inside.croydon@btinternet.com for our unbeatable ad rates
- If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, or want to publicise your residents’ association or business, or if you have a local event to promote, please email us with full details at inside.croydon@btinternet.com
As featured on Google News Showcase
- Our comments section on every report provides all readers with an immediate “right of reply” on all our content. Our comments policy can be read by clicking here
Inside Croydon is a member of the Independent Community News Network
The UK Health Security Agency acknowledges there is no safe threshold for NOx so nearby residents, especially in downwind wards in Croydon, will have been exposed to this excess air pollution known to trigger asthma, chest conditions and heart disease. It’s possible that infant mortality will also have increased locally above the high levels found after the incinerator started up in 2019. It’s awful that the ONS stopped publishing ward level infant mortality stats after that year (conveniently for Viridor), otherwise we could check the health effects for this vulnerable population after this long term exposure.
The Lib Dems in Sutton are in a cozy business relationship with Viridor and will do anything they possibly can to ignore Viridors failings . Were Viridor to get nasty and not connect their incinerator to the Lib Dems failing heat network. The heat network would be losing even more money than it does at present . One can imagine that the next Leaflets from Bobby Dean MP and from Cllr Lewis will be telling everyone that only they can stand up to Viridor . The fantasy world they live in is not one that I want to share and and it is beyond belief that these two have been able to hold positions of responsibility while not allowing a debate over the incinerator . I’m going to say it despite Lib Dems threat of defamation that in my personal opinion is that Sutton Lib Dem’s are unfit to run a whelk stall collectively or individually.
Even the slower-moving BBC have now got hold of the Beddington incinerator scandal. They say that Sutton Council have written to Steve Reed, the government’s worse-than-useless Environment Secretary, as if that will ever get anything done ?!
Meanwhile, the fume-belching incinerator continues to pump pollution, which continues to blow over Norbury (in Croydon).
ITV London News covering the story. Interviews with Nick Mattey and myself. There was a short clip this lunchtime news. More at 6pm evening news.
I saw the coverage on ITV at 6pm and the BBC at 6.30pm. The BBC item was just a 30-second news report with no interviews. Jim Duffy was on the ITV item and was a lot more articulate than Cllr Nick Mattey, who seemed like a real neanderthal ?!
Thanks Jim. I must say Nick worked very hard on this interview which lasted over an hour on his part. I think by the end it would have been quite tiring. Even then he went on to knock on a few doors with the reporter, getting feedback from local residents. The journalist was also top quality and has plans to come back and do more on incineration.
Many thanks to Inside Croydon for picking up the story so quickly making an excellent article which ITV News picked up on.
I did manage to help unspin the council narrative that Sutton were actually taking this seriously . The truth is Viridor pay Sutton council £1.4 million in business rates more than any other Sutton business When Sutton’s CEO is on £4700 a week this money is important. Sutton’s indignation is pure theatre
Pingback: Burn Baby Burn: Teesside’s incinerator craze continues