CROYDON COMMENTARY: Is the electorate being sold a pig in a poke over the “improving” state of the economy? ANDREW FISHER thinks so, and especially in London and particularly here in Croydon
In yesterday’s Guardian, Aditya Chakrabortty wrote a typically excellent piece on how “It’s not just the UK left behind by ‘booming London’. It’s Londoners too”.
He focused on his native Edmonton, on the northern edge of London. What struck me was how familiar this tale sounded at its southernmost edge too – in my native Croydon.
According to Trust for London, Croydon offers the lowest pay rates of any borough south of the river. The light industry that used to exist along the Purley Way is now replaced by retail and warehouses in much the same way as Chakrabortty describes for Edmonton. The only economic plan for the borough is more retail – with a new Westfield promised on the site of an existing shopping centre.
The future of high street retail is by no means secure – retail price deflation continues, sales staff are being replaced by automated check-outs, and consumers are shifting to online. Alongside the shopping centre, there will be a housing development, but only 15 per cent of the home will be “affordable”. On the plus side, the local Labour council is committed to becoming a living wage borough.
In the ward where I live child poverty (after housing costs) is 32.6 per cent, compared to a national average of 25.1 per cent. While in nearby Selhurst – home to the Premier League’s booming Crystal Palace – the child poverty rate is 41.4 per cent (full UK data here). Last year Croydon had among the highest number of children (77) living in temporary B&B accommodation.
Housing costs are a major driver of London’s poverty. Data compiled by The Economist shows that in Croydon’s three parliamentary constituencies house prices under this government have risen by 39.5 per cent in Croydon North, 29.3 per cent in Croydon Central and in Croydon South by 20.8 per cent. Pay across the UK is up only 7.5 per cent over the same period.
House prices are rising six times faster than wages – so that now the average London home costs £502,000, while the UK average is £272,000. For comparison, the median inner London wage is £34,500 (in outer London it’s £24,200) while the median UK wage is just £22,000. So house price to wage ratios in London are now around 14.5:1 (inner) or an eye-watering 20.5:1 (outer), meaning even a couple both earning the median wage could not feasibly get a mortgage – they are priced out.
The story is no better for the increasing number of tenants renting privately. Last year Croydon had the eighth highest rate of possession orders (when landlords are granted the right to evict tenants) of all English local authorities – and the second highest by number of orders. Around 1 in 20 of all Croydon residents are on the council housing waiting list.
It is no surprise then that due to the government’s benefit cap and Bedroom Tax policies, Croydon residents have been particularly hard hit: with 2,908 hit by the Bedroom Tax and 400 to 500 by the benefit cap, which was piloted in Croydon. In recent years, the council has deported its own citizens out of the borough to Essex, Wiltshire, East Sussex and Hampshire.
Despite boasts by the local Conservative candidates – something David Hencke has exposed – in Croydon Central, the unemployment rate (as opposed to the claimant count) has barely moved over the course of the last five years, dropping from 11.6 per cent to 11.0 per cent by the end of 2014 – higher than the London average of 7.0 per cent and the average across the country of 6.2 per cent (data via Nomisweb).
Croydon is by no means alone – even in many leafier central or west London boroughs there are enclaves of poverty – of people damaged by booming house prices, on zero hours contracts, working in low paying, non-unionised industries.
Chakrabortty is right: “London has been painted as a success story: a land of duckers and divers popping champagne whenever their houses go up by a grand a month”. That maybe true of the city’s voluble elite – championed by London’s buffoonish Toff mayor – but for millions of ordinary Londoners their life experiences are closer to those in the rest of country than they are to The City’s gilded few.
- Andrew Fisher is the author of The Failed Experiment and a regular contributor to the website of the Left Economics Advisory Panel. This is an edited version of an article first published by LEAP and reproduced here with permission
- For previous Inside Croydon articles by Andrew Fisher, click here
- Check out your General Election candidates at local hustings
- Inside Croydon’s coverage of the 2015 General Election
- Inside Croydon Events: for dates and links to what’s happening in and around Croydon, updated daily, click here
Inside Croydon: Named among best regional media campaigns, 2014.
- Croydon’s only independent news source, based in the heart of the borough: 729,297 page views in 2014.
- If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, a residents’ or business association or local event, please email us with full details at firstname.lastname@example.org