Croydon makes ‘Rotten Boroughs’ over £700k IT overspend

Back in the Eye: The scandal that just keeps giving – to Harry Singh

Nearly two months since a formal Town Hall investigation was begun into how one of the council’s most senior executives could hire a family friend on £787 per day without declaring their relationship, and the Borough Solicitor is still to deliver a ruling on the matter.

Inside Croydon exclusively revealed the scandal in October, reporting how Croydon’s assistant chief executive, Graham Cadle, was overseeing juicy payments for IT work to Harwinder “Harry” Singh. Cadle is the godfather to Singh’s child; the child’s mother, Karen Sullivan, is the council’s head of revenues and benefits who also reports to Cadle. None of the three ever voluntarily declared their cosy relationship, as would usually be required under the council’s code of conduct and most employment contracts. A simple breach of contract over a matter such as this, involving such large sums of public money, would normally require dismissal.

The Borough Solicitor, Jacqueline Harris-Baker, had ordered an investigation into the affair earlier this year, following concerns being raised by a whistle-blower. Confronted with the facts, the trio retrospectively declared their relationship… and then carried on as if nothing had changed.

In the meantime, Singh has been hard at work off-shoring to India much technical work on the council’s computer system, in a cost-cutting move which is seeing locally based IT technicians losing their work in Croydon just before Christmas. As also reported by Inside Croydon, Jo Negrini, the council’s chief executive, appears to believe that there is no risk to the personal data of tens of thousands of Croydon Council Tax-payers, parking permit applicants, but which IT experts working at the council’s say has “opened the door” to Croydon’s live data.

“We have opened up and given carte blanche access on the promise that the data will be kept secure,” they said, adding that Negrini has been “misinformed” over these serious security matters.

Private Eye: keeping watch on Croydon

All of which has now been reported in the latest issue of Private Eye, which is clearly fascinated in how a senior council officer can get away with paying a family friend at a day rate equivalent to £200,000 per year for a role for which their qualifications are at best dubious – anyone used Singh’s MyCroydon crap app lately? No? We thought not – and how the latest council cabinet meeting was blithely accepting an overspend on the late-running Singh-managed project of £700,000.

Negrini’s senior council officials, previously reluctant to investigate one of their colleagues, were forced to do so in October when Sean Fitzsimons, the Labour councillor who chairs the scrutiny committee, took the concerns of the IT whistleblower to Harris-Baker. The Borough Solicitor ordered a second investigation into the conduct of Cadle, Singh and Sullivan.

Since when… tumbleweed.

One in the Eye: Simon Hall

“The council’s senior executives are a law unto themselves,” one senior Katharine Street source said today. “This is just another example of how out of control Negrini and her colleagues are – virtually untouchable by the likes of the so-called ‘strong leader’ Tony Newman and councillors. That’s how we arrived at the Ofsted crisis over children’s services: senior officers just lied to cover their arses.”

The fantasy that Croydon’s councillors have any control over the full-time professional staff running Fisher’s Folly is highlighted in the widely read “Rotten Boroughs” column in the latest issue of the Eye, which reports, “Having a council executive paying a family friend £787.36 per day is ‘a model of behaviour for other councils’, according to Croydon’s cabinet member for finance, Simon Hall…

“… Hall revealed that the project had overspent its £8.4m budget by at least £700,000 and won’t be completed until next year – at least nine months late. According to Hall, this was delivering, ‘ICT infrastructure at lesser cost and with a lot more control’.”

Hall, like all members of the council’s cabinet, is reliant on detailed briefings from senior council officials. Often, indeed, the very same people who created the mess.

  • Inside Croydon is a member of the Independent Community News Network
  • Inside Croydon is the borough’s only independent news source, and still based in the heart of Croydon
  • 1 MILLION PAGE VIEWS IN 2017 (January to September)
  • If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, a residents’ or business association or a local event to publicise, please email us with full details at

About insidecroydon

News, views and analysis about the people of Croydon, their lives and political times in the diverse and most-populated borough in London. Based in Croydon and edited by Steven Downes. To contact us, please email
This entry was posted in Croydon Council, Graham Cadle, Jacqueline Harris-Baker, Jo Negrini, Sean Fitzsimons and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Croydon makes ‘Rotten Boroughs’ over £700k IT overspend

  1. They obviously think that keeping quite and pretending everything is ok, then this will quietly be forgotten. WRONG!

    “Digital enabling” is also a long running euphemism for spending shed loads of money with consultants on systems that go over budget, over time and fail to deliver on promises – i.e.actually work properly (apart from making staff redundant that is).

  2. Please TWEET this!!!

  3. A thing with the IT upper management in Croydon Council is that they are not IT literate enough to understand the project requirements.
    They get in consultants who do a lot of chin rubbing and pull figures from god knows where.
    Too much tech talk and they are too embarassed to say I don’t understand.

    • To be fair, that much has been obvious since the wool was pulled over people’s eyes with the crap app, My Croydon, and the manner in which that was commissioned by Cadle, on the quiet, unannounced or debated in public, from a bloke operating out of a flat in Battersea…

Leave a Reply