By-election rivals say LibDem candidate unfit for public office

CARL SHILTON reports on the cross-party condemnations for a council by-election candidate who has overseen failed businesses that have left multi-million-pound debts

Assembly Member Caroline Pidgeon, left, and LibDem Mayoral candidate Siobhan Benita were quick to show support for failed businessman Barry Lewis

Barry Lewis, the choice of Sutton’s Liberal Democrats to be parachuted in to Wallington North for the council by-election later this month, has succeeded in one thing already: unifying his political rivals in their condemnation of his suitability for elected office.

Inside Sutton revealed earlier this week that Lewis is a director of two companies that are in liquidation with a trail of debts – including to the taxman – of nearly £9million.

Lewis and the leader of Sutton’s LibDems, Ruth Dombey, have refused to answer questions about the candidate’s business background, or about whether the local party exercised due diligence in checking public records, such as from Companies House, to establish whether Lewis is a fit and proper person to seek elected office.

The Wallington North by-election has been called for March 28, after the resignation of LibDem councillor Joyce Melican.

Other parties with candidates in the by-election maintain that they would take greater care over how they select someone to represent the public.

Charlie Mansell, the Sutton Labour official, said, “It is clear that the LibDems have something to answer about their candidate’s business dealings.

“In recent weeks they have had to suspend from their party in the middle of an election a candidate who Tom Brake MP had publicly supported, but who was shown to have supported anti-Semitic statements. The LibDems should immediately issue a statement over the due diligence that they conducted over this current candidate and whether he disclosed his business dealings as part of it.

“They should also state to the public whether they are now satisfied with the standards of their candidate’s business dealings, bearing in mind if elected they will hold a responsible public position concerned with Council Tax-payers’ money.”

Lewis’s election leaflet sees him seeking to get his hands on increased public funding for police

That issue, of responsibility for public money, is something which has concerned Peter Underwood, the Green Party’s London Assembly candidate for Sutton and Croydon. Underwood told Inside Sutton: “Voters have a right to expect high standards from people elected to public office. In these times of Conservative Government cuts to local authority funding, the ability to manage finances in a responsible way is especially important.

“Voters should ask themselves whether someone with a history of directing companies into liquidation is the right person to represent them on the council.”

Nick Mattey, the independent councillor in Beddington North, said, “This LibDem candidate is demanding that Sutton Council is given more government money to fund the police. In fact, it’s his only campaign theme. Mr Lewis must know that when a company goes bust owing £220,000 to HMRC, that lost money could have been funding our police force.

“Should we be considering electing someone who is part of a company that cannot successfully manage its own financial affairs, and who will have responsibility for millions of pounds of taxpayers’ money in Sutton?

“Maybe he’s standing for election because he needs the money. LibDem councillors receive on average an eye-watering £19,700 a year each for what is often a part-time job.”

And Tim Crowley, the leader of Sutton Council’s opposition Conservatives, said, “If the company owed the taxman such large sums of money as happened with one of the firms where Barry Lewis was a director, then they must have (a) made a lot of money or (b) taken the PAYE or NI off their employees and not paid it over.

“Running a small company myself and having to manage cashflow, VAT and PAYE, I know how difficult it can be, but I am also very aware when we sometimes get stretched. Businesses do go under. However, I wonder if the LibDems had full disclosure from Mr Lewis when they selected him?”

There is no suggestion of any wrongdoing by Lewis in these company transactions. Indeed, this week, figures within Sutton LibDems confirmed that what Inside Sutton had discovered in the public records was entirely accurate.

Following the publication of the result of our investigation, one Sutton LibDem made statements in online public forums to the effect that Lewis had done no wrong in his buisness dealings, and that his involvement as a director of Cello Aviation Ltd in November 2017 was in some way altruistic, in an effort to save the company from collapse.

MP Tom Brake: has been very quiet about Barry Lewis this week

The facts of the matter are these: on October 25 last year, Lewis and his fellow directors of Cello Aviation put the company into voluntary liquidation with total liabilities of £8.58million, including £220,000 owed to Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs in respect of PAYE, £226,200 for employee redundancy payments, and £153,400 in wage arrears and holiday pay.

The LibDems have refused to answer questions about whether Lewis disclosed details of his failed businesses when under-going their “rigorous” selection process.

Tom Brake, the LibDem MP for Carshalton and Wallington, has been notably silent about Lewis since our investigation was made public. Brake was badly embarrassed last month when he supported the LibDem candidate in another London council by-election who turned out to be an anti-Semite, and who was suspended from the party on the eve of polling day.

Carshalton resident Lewis, 58, is a long-time travel industry businessman who describes himself as a “consultant” at

According to his own election literature, he has also been a scout leader for 25 years.

What is not on his leaflets is that Lewis has been a member of the Liberal Democrats in Sutton only since 2015. With Lewis refusing to answer media enquiries regarding his conduct over his business failures, it is difficult to establish with any certainty what else the LibDems are keeping out of their election leaflets and from the people of Sutton about their candidate.

Lewis is one of seven candidates for Wallington North; the others have been declared as:

John Bannon – UKIP
Sheila Berry – Labour
Ashley Dickenson – Christian Peoples Alliance
Charlotte Leonard – Conservative
Gervais Sawyer – Independent
Verity Thomson – Green

About insidecroydon

News, views and analysis about the people of Croydon, their lives and political times in the diverse and most-populated borough in London. Based in Croydon and edited by Steven Downes. To contact us, please email
This entry was posted in Barry Lewis, Charlie Mansell, Nick Mattey, Ruth Dombey, Sutton Council, Tim Crowley, Tom Brake MP and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to By-election rivals say LibDem candidate unfit for public office

  1. Mike Buckley says:

    Why worry? Thee are five other candidates from which to choose, you dont have to vote for him.
    Clearly LibDem think he IS SUITABLE or he would not have been selected, so if you think differently you know what to do!

    • Why worry? Because in a one-party state such as Sutton, without anyone watching what the LibDems are up to, they thought they could parachute Lewis in and take the electorate for mugs.
      Would you have known of Lewis’s business background if not for our investigation report?

  2. Hatim Chakera says:

    Aren’t most of the Councillors in Croydon too?

    • No.
      Cheap gag which ignores the importance of the matter.
      And isn’t even funny.

      • Mike Buckley says:

        Sorry, if I gave the wrong imoression, as was intending to say you wont vote for him will you, now that you know all the facts, but the likely truth is that people will vote for him, blindly perhaps, but they will do it!

Leave a Reply