Ali refuses to support Newman and Hall for public office

CROYDON IN CRISIS: Splits in the local Labour Party are deepening as recriminations mount over Tony Newman’s 15 years of misrule.

Hamida Ali and her former mentor Tony Newman: she could not express support for him when questioned by MPs

Hamida Ali, the one-time political protégé of discredited council leader Tony Newman, yesterday refused to offer her support to him for any future public role.

Councillor Ali, the leader of Croydon Council who succeeded Newman in that role, was being questioned by MPs in a Parliamentary select committee that spent two hours picking over the bones of the council’s financial collapse.

Andrew Lewer is a member of the committee and the Conservative MP for Northampton South, so has some direct experience of local authorities that go bust and are forced to issue a Section 114 notice: before Croydon issued its S114 in November 2020, Tory-run Northamptonshire County Council in 2018 had been the first authority in 20 years to effectively declare itself bankrupt.

Ali had already been nearly two hours’ worth of grilling by the MPs when Lewer was called upon to take his turn in the round of questioning.

Pointed questions: Tory MP Andrew Lewer

Ali had been a cabinet member for nearly five years under Newman, Lewer observed. Why had she failed to notice, or do anything, about the impending disaster that was facing the council?

Ali spoke about her last 18 months as a cabinet member, when she said she had become “increasingly concerned about the budget-setting” and had been “more and more frustrated” by a lack of detailed and reliable information, both from her cabinet colleagues and from council officials, with many of the more important discussions happening in non-public meetings of the cabinet and Labour group.

Lewer sprang his trap. “Given that frustration and not having the full picture, that you’ve described very well, would I be right in assuming that the previous leader and cabinet lead finance wouldn’t have your support for future public office?” Lewer said.

It is, in essence, a pretty binary question.

But Ali refused to voice her support for Newman or Simon Hall, the former cabinet member for finance, ever holding public office again.

Noting that both Newman and Hall had stood down from their council positions and had resigned as councillors, Ali said, “I’m conscious they’re not here to reply for themselves, so I’ll leave it at that.”

Newman and Hall have engaged lawyers (“leading Counsel’s” [sic] according to Newman) over references to them in the council’s Penn Report, which was commissioned to look into possible wrong-doing over the past four years at the Town Hall. That report led to a complaint to the Labour Party nationally and their suspension from the party.

The knowledge of that legal dispute probably restricted Ali in her comments in response to Lewer’s question. Parliamentary privilege only goes so far…

The internecine fighting within Croydon Labour appears to be ramping up, too, as Ali effectively turned her back on two of her erstwhile closest colleagues at the council.

Bitter: Simon Hall’s ‘Hamida Ali administration tweet was quickly deleted, but offers further evidence in splits between Newman’s regime and the new cabinet

On Wednesday night, as the scandal over the state of some council flats in South Norwood was played out across national television, Hall broke cover to tweet in response to a public plea from Fransoy Hewitt, the young mother featured in the ITV News reports.

“Can councillors [Patsy Cummings] and [Clive Fraser] please help this victim of [Hamida Ali’s] administration?” Hall tweeted, somewhat disingenuously. Hewitt and her neighbours’ complaints had begun before Ali had become leader, and while Alison Butler, another member of Newman and Hall’s clique, was still in charge of housing in the borough.

Hall quickly deleted his ill-considered bit of grandstanding, though not before Inside Croydon’s loyal reader screengrabbed it.

Ali and her Labour colleagues have five ward by-elections to contest on May 6, and as a consequence of the bitter recriminations following 15 years of Newman’s leadership of the local party, may struggle to find activists prepared to canvass or leaflet on their behalf.

Read more: Newman and Hall resign as councillors claiming a ‘witchhunt’
Read more:
‘Why do you appear not to know the answer to anything?’
Read more:
Croydon shamed over ‘dangerous squalor’ in council flats
Read more: ‘Is it because the council don’t care? Where is their humanity?’

  • If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, or want to publicise your residents’ association or business, or if you have a local event to promote, please email us with full details at
  • Inside Croydon is a member of the Independent Community News Network
  • Inside Croydon works together with the Bureau of Investigative Journalism and BBC London News
  • ROTTEN BOROUGH AWARDS: Croydon was named the country’s rottenest borough in 2020 in the annual round-up of civic cock-ups in Private Eye magazine – the fourth successive year that Inside Croydon has been the source for such award-winning nominations
  • Inside Croydon: 3million page views in 2020. Seen by 1.4million unique visitors

About insidecroydon

News, views and analysis about the people of Croydon, their lives and political times in the diverse and most-populated borough in London. Based in Croydon and edited by Steven Downes. To contact us, please email
This entry was posted in Alison Butler, Croydon Council, Hamida Ali, New Addington North, Section 114 notice, Simon Hall, Tony Newman and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Ali refuses to support Newman and Hall for public office

  1. Everybody in Croydon who received their Croydon Council Tax bill this week and were disappointed that it had gone up by the maximum amount will understand its typical of most councils in London.

    But when they receive the same bill in 5 years time and it’s still at its maximum increase, unlike other London boroughs, they can thank the cretinous Simon Hall and Tony Newman for that.

    The effects of their financial ineptitude, secret behind closed doors decisions and lack of accountability, and now remorse, will cast a shadow over this Borough fir a generation.

    I have one thing today to both of them: please f**k off.

  2. Hans Mien says:

    Sounds familiar. I knew it was going on and did fu** all. We’re you complicit or loved ya pay cheque more than being honest with yourself. Can you really trust this flimsy so called leader.

  3. miapawz says:

    £2700 for a 1200 square foot 3 bed is what we pay. That’s what you pay to have a bin emptied every 2 weeks. I have no kids and comit no crime…. I am happy to ‘contribute’ but I feel I’m paying for Negreedy and shifty’s huge allowance but not for the poor people who deserve support or for any social care. I’d rather they were all sacked and Grant Thornton took over.

Leave a Reply