Garratt doubles victory margin as he takes City Hall seat

NOT-SO-SPECIAL ELECTION SPECIAL: Labour has slipped back in the London Assembly voting, with its worst result in Croydon and Sutton for 13 years. By WALTER CRONXITE, political editor

Arse!: Neil ‘Father Ted’ Garratt is the first Sutton-based Assembly Member

Neil “Father Jack” Garratt was named on Saturday as Croydon and Sutton’s London Assembly Member – only the third Assembly Member to represent this super-constituency of more than 430,000 voters in the 21-year history of the GLA, and all of them have been Tories.

Garratt takes over from “Silent” Steve O’Connell, who has retired from public office (not that anyone would notice).

Garratt did not waste much time after the vote declaration held at Olympia from posting a self-regarding tweet once it was confirmed that the Sutton councillor had attracted 75,246 votes – 18,271 more than Labour candidate Patsy Cummings.

That margin of victory is more than double the number of votes that separated Tory and Labour candidates in 2012, and nearly 8,000 more than the victory margin in 2016, when Marina Ahmad was Labour’s candidate.

Ahmad switched constituencies, running in Lambeth and Southwark this time round, and so the former Bromley councillor (she stood down there because of her likely responsibilities at City Hall) became the first Muslim woman elected to the London Assembly.

Second time lucky: 2016 Croydon and Sutton candidate Marina Ahmad will now be holding Sadiq Khan to account at City Hall

Given the lacklustre campaign waged by Cummings and disappointing outcome, it might be a while before the councillor in South Norwood ward manages to match Ahmad’s achievements.

In a week of serious electoral concerns for Croydon Labour, the 1.85 per cent swing from Labour to the Conservatives in Croydon and Sutton Assembly seat was in line with the London-wide swing to the Tories on the Assembly.

The turnout in these covid elections was higher than expected, with 42 per cent.

The full vote was as follows

Garratt Conservative 75,246 41.4% (up 2.8% on 2016)
Cummings Labour 56,975 31.3% (down 0.9%)
Bonham Liberal Democrat 26,258 14.4% (up 4%)
Underwood Green 18,069 9.9% (up 2.5%)
Poll Reform UK 3,190 1.8%
Sampson Let London Live 2,021 1.1%

Conservative majority: 18,271

The result makes 2012, when Louisa Woodley lost by 9,418, the high watermark for Labour in this seat.

Garratt will be the seat’s first Sutton-based representative. His over-40 per cent score has only been achieved twice before, by O’Connell in 2008 and Andrew Pelling in 2000.

Patsy Cummings’ close association with the dodgy Croydon cabal of Tony Newman did her no favours at the polls

Cummings will have hoped that Sadiq Khan’s commanding lead in the opinion polls over Tory rival Shaun Bailey might have been enough to have carried her to City Hall on the Mayor’s coat-tails.

But Khan’s early lead was whittled away, and the Labour Mayor only got 40 per cent of the vote on first preferences, down 4.2 per cent on 2016.

It was this slight downturn in support for Labour that saw the party lose one of its three AMs from the London-wide list, while the Greens (up to three seats) and LibDems (two) both gained seats, as past support for far-right Brexit parties evaporated.

Khan’s reputation as a possible competitor with another Mayor, Andy Burnham, to lead the Labour Party will also have been damaged by a poor showing against a widely derided Tory candidate.

Sutton’s LibDems, having lost both MPs in the borough, will take some comfort managing to scramble third place, encouraging their hopes to retian control of their council next year.

The fourth place for the Green’s Peter Underwood will disappoint his party. who hoped to emerge as the clear third-placed party in local politics. Underwood was, though, a clear but distant third in the Woodside council by-election held on the same day.

By contrast, in neighbouring Lambeth and Southwark Assembly election, the Greens were second behind Ahmad.

The very low showing for the Croydon and Sutton Reform candidate will have aided the Tory cause.

Polling day also saw two referendums held in the capital on directly elected mayoral systems.

Newham and Tower Hamlets both already have elected mayors. Newham electors were given a choice between continuing to have an elected mayor or changing to a council committee system. There, they opted to stay with the mayoralty with a 56 per cent vote.

In Tower Hamlets, all the main parties recommended dropping the mayoral system and using instead the “Strong” leader model, which has been used in Croydon. The Tower Hamlets voters ignored the parties and voted 77.8 per cent in favour of keeping their mayoral system.

These strong votes for mayors will encourage Croydon’s DEMOC campaign ahead of the referendum that they have secured for October 7.

Read more: Tories are tipped to cling on to Croydon and Sutton seat
Read more: Conservatives’ anti-London policies have put Bailey in the dock
Read more: Tory Assembly candidate in racism row over stop and search

  • If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, want to publicise your residents’ association or business, or if you have a local event to promote, please email us with full details at
  • Inside Croydon is a member of the Independent Community News Network
  • Inside Croydon works together with the Bureau of Investigative Journalism and BBC London News
  • ROTTEN BOROUGH AWARDS: Croydon was named the country’s rottenest borough in 2020 in the annual round-up of civic cock-ups in Private Eye magazine – the fourth successive year that Inside Croydon has been the source for such award-winning nominations
  • Inside Croydon: 3million page views in 2020. Seen by 1.4million unique visitors

About insidecroydon

News, views and analysis about the people of Croydon, their lives and political times in the diverse and most-populated borough in London. Based in Croydon and edited by Steven Downes. To contact us, please email
This entry was posted in 2021 London elections, London Assembly, London-wide issues, Marina Ahmad, Mayor of London, Neil Garratt, Patsy Cummings, Sadiq Khan, Shaun Bailey, South Norwood, Sutton Council and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Garratt doubles victory margin as he takes City Hall seat

  1. Alan Stanton says:

    Revealed as the Rottenest borough by Inside Croydon and Private Eye can’t have helped.
    On the other hand Johnson must be in the running for rottenest Prime Minister at least until vaccines arrived..

  2. It’s fair to say that the Tower Hamlets mayoral vote likely had more to do with the potential return of the…ahem.. prodigal son Lutfur Rahman than any disillusion with the parties, or indeed a rational preference for one model over another.

    Another thing worth observing of course, is the share of the progressive vote. Had Father Jack faced a single candidate he’d likely have lost. This might be all the more important if the long run if the government reverts to FPTP…

  3. Mark says:

    I’m not surprised with the increased majority for Tory Garratt, I live in a Labour ward in Croydon (not one with a by-election on the same day) and had a constant stream of leaflets from The Conservative Party in the run up to the Assembly election (all delivered by Royal Mail). The final count was eight from them, and only two from Labour and one from the Green Party.

    • On leaflet count in the London Assembly and Mayoral elections, Inside Croydon Towers received just one: from the Communist Party.

      It’s almost as if Croydon’s Labour and Tories are avoiding us, or the Greens and LibDems can’t afford too many leaflets.

Leave a Reply