Feeling let down: marchers at yesterday’s Clean Water demo are demanding that the water industry is re-nationalised by the Labour government. Steve Reed, meanwhile, has been holding secret meetings with water industry bosses
Our environment correspondent, PAUL LUSHION, reports on how the tide of support for one local MP in government is going out very quickly
Steve Reed, the Croydon MP promoted to environment secretary in Keir Starmer’s government, is rapidly finding himself out of his depth in a sea of sewage… and worse.
Knee-deep in sewage: smirking Steve Reed is causing increasing distrust over government policy on pollution
Devoted townie Reed was quickly found out by the farming lobby, who are ready to march on Westminster after changes in inheritance tax announced in last week’s Budget.
But he is also being deserted by celebrity supporters, who spotted Reed on the anti-pollution bandwagon before the General Election but have since discovered the Labour MP for Streatham and Croydon North is really doing next to nothing over the dumping of sewage into our rivers, lakes and along our coastlines.
Now Reed has been exposed as having attended a series of meetings with the water bosses, which were all kept secret and strictly “off the record”. Which some might think an odd way of using public officials’ time. And others might suggest is downright suspicious…
Tens of thousands of people from more than 130 of the country’s most prominent environment, nature, fishing, water sports and community organisations, representing 10.1million supporters, flooded the streets of central London yesterday for the March for Clean Water.
Cut the crap: this protestor has obviously encountered Steve Reed before
Greenpeace, one of the organisations who helped co-ordinate the march, said, “Environmental advocates, community leaders and citizens from every part of the UK – from Scotland to Cornwall – marched to call an end to the pollution caused by multiple sources, including water companies and intensive agriculture.”
The marchers had three main demands:
- Stop pollution for profit
- Reform our failed environmental regulators
- Actually enforce the laws that already exist to deter and punish illegal pollution
“Campaigners remain deeply concerned that despite multiple commitments made during the recent General Election campaign to take resolute action to address the issue, they do not go nearly far enough to address the root causes of water pollution,” Greenpeace say.
An intervention last week by Reed, who wrote to activists saying they could trust him with persuading the water industry to change, was met with anger by campaigners who said he was avoiding the key issue – that water privatisation has failed.
The latest move by the privatised water industry is a huge hike in the bills paid by households to pay for remedial improvement works – effectively another massive public subsidy for their shareholders.
Ash Smith, of Windrush against Sewage, one of the speakers at yesterday’s rally, said, “There is massive public support to end the scandal that privatisation has brought. Reed’s refusal to face the facts and to rely on water company-funded fiction about costs is setting captive bill payers up to bail out private equity and keep the unforgivable exploitation going on for another five years.”
Today, Greenpeace said: “The measures that have been published in the government’s Water (Special Measures) Bill do not address the chronic failure of regulation in recent years, where environmental laws and regulations have failed to be enforced by environmental protection agencies, allowing polluters to regularly break the law and poison our water with impunity.”
Giles Bristow, the chief executive of Surfers Against Sewage, one of the bodies who organised the march, said, “We’re marching because we’re sick of surfing in shit, it’s that simple.
“No more cover-ups, no more excuses, no more delays, we are here to reclaim our rivers, lakes and seas from the profiteering fat cats of the water industry and to demand an end to sewage pollution, for good.”
None of the people on yesterday’s march will be impressed, therefore, to hear that Reed and senior civil servants have been attending a series of meetings with water bosses where there were never any minutes taken.
The Good Law Project reports that since the General Election in July, “Labour policy on the water industry has gradually softened.” They appear to be surprised…
Fresh flow: the Clean Water demonstration drew together protestors from more than 130 organisations
They report that senior officials at the environment department met with water companies nine times between July and September. But no minutes were taken.
“Responding to our Freedom of Information request, the department told us that the environment secretary…”, meaning Reed himself, “… ministers responsible for water and flooding and other officials have attended these meetings. The department gave no details about which firms turned up, and declared that, ‘We do not hold any minutes of the meetings you have asked about’.”
Since becoming environment secretary, Reed has ruled out re-nationalisation of the water industry. Some tougher measures that were expected to be included in Reed’s water bill have also been quietly dropped.
The Good Law Project reports, “A clause in the bill could allow costs of bailing out underperforming companies to be transferred to bill-payers… [Reed’s] department was relying on analysis paid for by the water industry to push back against public ownership – analysis that was deemed ‘economically illiterate’ by leading economists.”
Tamara Walters, of the Good Law Project, said, “For all their talk of clearing up the Tory sewage scandal, ministers seem determined to make exactly the same mistakes.
“So it’s both shocking and all too familiar to find that they’ve been meeting water bosses off the record. If ministers talk to big business, we need to know what they’re saying. We need to know they’re working for us, and not for shareholders.”
Read more: ‘I don’t think it’s helpful you ask questions like this’ squirms MP Reed
Read more: Suited and booted: Norbury Alli’s donations and No10 access
Read more: MP Reed’s farming cuts get Keir barred from Clarkson’s pub
Read more: #TheLabourFiles: MP Reed, Evans and the Croydon connection
FREE ADS: Paid-up subscribers to Inside Croydon qualify for a free ad for their business, residents’ association or community group, just one of the benefits of being part of our online community. For more information about being an iC subscriber, click here for our Patreon page
PAID ADS: To advertise your services or products to our near 10,000 weekday visitors to the site, which is featured on Google News Showcase and followed by 16,000 on Twitter/X, email us inside.croydon@btinternet.com for our unbeatable ad rates
- If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, or want to publicise your residents’ association or business, or if you have a local event to promote, please email us with full details at inside.croydon@btinternet.com
As featured on Google News Showcase
- Our comments section on every report provides all readers with an immediate “right of reply” on all our content. Our comments policy can be read by clicking here
Inside Croydon is a member of the Independent Community News Network
- Inside Croydon works together with the Bureau of Investigative Journalism, as well as BBC London News and ITV London
ROTTEN BOROUGH AWARDS: In January 2024, Croydon was named among the country’s rottenest boroughs for a SEVENTH successive year in the annual round-up of civic cock-ups in Private Eye magazine
What was described as a “bit less shit” in Croydon? Was that having a directly elected mayor? If so, piss-poor Perry seems determined to prove that it is definitely another mistake.
Meanwhile, long-time local government gravy train passenger (in Lambeth), Steve Reed, upgraded to the more lucrative Parliamentary (a.k.a. national government) gravy train (as Croydon North) MP) and is racing Powerless Perry to the bottom by allowing (greedy) water companies to share around a “lot more shit”.
Steve Reed doesn’t seem to be having too much success in any of his posts in recent years, does he?
When he was Shadow Local Government Secretary (2020-2021) his own borough
(Croydon) declared itself bankrupt.
When he was Shadow Justice Secretary (2021-2023) he was named as recipient of emails unlawfully hacked from the website of a well-known local blog.
Now, after being Environment Secretary for less than four months, he’s being taken to task for the reasons mentioned in this article.
Unminuted meetings? As David Bowie would put it, “it’s so fucking Croydon Labour”
Ahhh… so you remember the Report In The Public Interest that criticised Tony Newman’s Labour council for having no notes of important meetings about multi-million-pound property deals.
When will the people realise that Reed is a selfish careerist who puts himself first then party and bottom of the pile are the people. His track record in his old patch of S Norwood is appalling. He is where he is not on merit or knowledge but because of friendship with the power broker in No10
Looks like Mr Reed has voted here!