CROYDON IN CRISIS: The council-owned arts centre, refurbished at a cost of £70m, is closing its doors to 200 fee-paying pupils in what one councillor describes as ‘a loss to the community’. EXCLUSIVE by STEVEN DOWNES
Not so bright: venue operators BH Live appear to be determined to shut down
Croydon, London’s “Borough of Culture” in 2023, is closing its biggest music school in 2024.
The Yamaha Music School is being forced out of the council-owned Fairfield Halls, its home for the past five years, where around 200 youngsters – and some not-so-young – pay up to £20 a time for a range of lessons and one-hour group sessions on keyboards, drums and guitar.
The decision to end the music school’s use of the Fairfield Halls has been taken by the venue’s managers, Bournemouth-based leisure centre operators BH Live. Neither BH Live nor Croydon Council responded to Inside Croydon’s requests for comment.
Yamaha Music Schools operate around the world, using a well-respected formula for developing musical skills and talents of all ages.
Final fanfare: the Halls managers are kicking the music school out
The licensing deal to bring the Yamaha Music School to Croydon was one of the few enduring successes at the Fairfield Halls since it re-opened in 2019, following the controversial and uncompleted £70million council-funded refurbishment.
As well as securing a regular income stream for the venue – BHLive retained all profits from the music school – the arrangement also provided youthful footfall at the under-utilised venue throughout the week, even when BH Live’s artistic programme has been otherwise underwhelming.
And under special arrangements during a series of international classical concerts held in 2022 and 2023, many of the young pupils were able to attend special rehearsals in the Concert Hall with world-famous professional musicians.
Croydon’s Yamaha Music School’s annual Christmas concert at the Fairfield Halls, due to be staged on December 7, seems likely to be the last at the venue.
An email was sent to the school’s pupils last week.
“We are writing to let you know that at the end of this winter term (from Sunday 15 December 2024), the Yamaha Music School (YMS) at Fairfield Halls will close,” it stated, tersely.
There are hopes that the Croydon school will continue to operate, from an alternative venue.
Well-taught: the Yamaha Music School in Croydon had 200 pupils on its books at any one time
But given the massive investment in the Fairfield Halls, and its supposed status as the borough’s cultural centre, the decision by BH Live to end their licensing arrangement with Yamaha from the end of this year appears, at best, perverse.
It comes not long after a programme of organ music recitals, using the Concert Hall’s prized instrument that had been refurbished at significant cost, were also scrapped by the management. Two artistic directors have resigned their jobs at the Fairfield Halls since 2020, the latest, Jonathan Higgins, never having been replaced by his employers, BH Live.
The decision over the Yamaha Music School will do nothing to provide assurance to those who have been critical of BH Live’s Philistine approach to the arts, its poor, almost non-existent promotion of some shows, and the lack of investment in the musical and artistic programmes at the once-admired south London venue.
One ward councillor, Esther Sutton, has called the decision “disappointing” and “a loss to the community”.
Sutton is a Green Party councillor for Fairfield ward, but also runs The Oval Tavern, with its renowned programme of musical performances most nights – so she knows a thing or two about the local cultural scene, promoting the arts and the importance of public participation in the Fairfield Halls.
“It is disappointing to learn BH Live will no longer be hosting the Yamaha Music School at the Fairfield Halls – a loss to the community.
Hopes for a new venue: Bethany Norman had managed the YMS at the Fairfield Halls for the past five years
“Our important venue should be fostering Croydon’s emerging talent, providing grassroots support and making music truly accessible for young musicians in our diverse borough.”
Bethany Norman has been managing the YMS programme on behalf of the venue for the past five years, and she says that she plans to continue delivering the Yamaha teaching programme.
“We have had a great five years at the Fairfield Halls and I am grateful for the opportunities it has offered.
“There is no denying that I am disappointed that BH Live haven’t shown dedication to developing their Yamaha Music School to work within their business model in Croydon.
“However, I truly believe this is just the beginning for YMS Croydon.”
Read more: How businesses profited at expense of the Borough of Culture
Read more: Fairfield Halls left haunted by acts from its more glorious past
Read more: Anyone followed the Music Heritage Trail? Or even found it?
Read more: Talawa’s plays in search of an audience: the acts deserve better
- The Garwood Foundation is Inside Croydon’s nominated charity for 2024.
- To find out more about their vitally important work, click here
- To donate, click here
FREE ADS: Paid-up subscribers to Inside Croydon qualify for a free ad for their business, residents’ association or community group, just one of the benefits of being part of our online community. For more information about being an iC subscriber, click here for our Patreon page
PAID ADS: To advertise your services or products to our near 10,000 weekday visitors to the site, which is featured on Google News Showcase and followed by 16,000 on Twitter/X, email us inside.croydon@btinternet.com for our unbeatable ad rates
- If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, or want to publicise your residents’ association or business, or if you have a local event to promote, please email us with full details at inside.croydon@btinternet.com
As featured on Google News Showcase
- Our comments section on every report provides all readers with an immediate “right of reply” on all our content. Our comments policy can be read by clicking here
Inside Croydon is a member of the Independent Community News Network
- Inside Croydon works together with the Bureau of Investigative Journalism, as well as BBC London News and ITV London
ROTTEN BOROUGH AWARDS: In January 2024, Croydon was named among the country’s rottenest boroughs for a SEVENTH successive year in the annual round-up of civic cock-ups in Private Eye magazine
Croydon. No shopping centre to speak of. No music school. No Post Office. No renewal. No political leadership. No money. No heart. No soul. No hope
Now the Borough of No Culture….
No stand at Croydon Arena either. No-one answering the phone when you ring them, Many employees who won’t give their name etc
I’m as angry as the others who have commented here, but facebook and other groups suggest that lots of people who used to live in the town are sad to see its level of decay. I see few comments from current residents who don’t remember Croydon as it was. Are most of Croydon’s population satisfied with the way the town looks and feels now, or are they not intending to stay here long enough to care? I went to school in Wellesley Road, worked in most of the town’s offices including the Town Hall, and brought my children up here. I now split my time between Croydon and France. Am I in a small minority that still gives a damn? Thank heaven for Inside Croydon, the voice of sanity in a town I can hardly recognise as home.
The only ‘positive’ outcome I can see would be that it may be Whitgift’s gain, if they have a suitable venue to let YMS Croydon?
Fairfield don’t seem to have announced many classical concerts recently from touring international orchestras. Are the Halls still on the circuit for 2025, or is moving away from classical music their new strategy?
I am so shocked by this news but not surprised. I would like to know what Croydon council spent the money on that they got for being the borough of culture, which I thought was laughable at the time. I am a long time resident of Croydon and I am dismayed. Surely having a music school in Croydon is a way to keep people coming in! Do better Croydon!!
I am moving out from Croydon shit hole as soon as I can. This borough has no future. All services down, Westfield regeneration project maybe completed in 10 years from now if we are lucky, drug dealers and beggars every corner, thieves, ect. Mr Mayor Perry, the only way to keep people in Croydon is to make this place safe again. At the moment there is no hope. I know many people moving out somewhere else. It is just easier to move out that wait another 20 years for improvement . It is like this music school closing down, why? No sense at all. If the council would be a private company believe me everyone would be fired long time ago. This borough has no time for those incompetent people to manage it.
Mr Mayor, I know libraries are important but please, those are useless if you get killed on the way to it.
I’d be interested to test whether the terms of any grants received by the Council or BH Live for the refurbishment and operation have been breached by the management decision to end most community uses of the halls.
The biggest grant came from Coast to Capital. £8m. It was to pay for an underground art gallery. That has definitely not been delivered, nor the grant refunded.