CROYDON COMMENTARY: Ahead of the council’s more-heat-than-light annual Budget meetings that begin this week, PETER UNDERWOOD highlights how the councillors of one party at the Town Hall are presenting some realistic proposals
Honesty and fairness.
They are the themes of the Green Party’s amendments to Mayor Jason Perry’s Budget proposals for Croydon Council, “Honesty about the mess we are in and fairness in making those who can afford to lose more face the biggest cuts.”
While Conservative and Labour councillors are looking to give themselves a pay rise, Green councillors are calling for SRAs – Special Responsibility Allowances – to be cut by 50%, so that money can go to saving jobs in frontline services.
Mayor Perry is facing the first of two scheduled budget-setting meetings at the Town Hall on Wednesday, when the 2025-2026 Council Tax will also be determined (the proposal is for it to increase by 4.99% from April, giving Croydon residents the second highest Council Tax in London).
Over the last two years, Green councillors have voted against Mayor Perry’s Budgets and called on the government to fund Croydon fairly. The position in the Town Hall Chamber since the 2022 local elections is that the Conservatives have power in the elected Mayor, but on the rare occasions anything is actually put to a vote, there are 37 Labour, Green and LibDem councillors, and only 33 Conservatives.
Council Tax hike: Croydon’s Greens have voted against tax increases in 2023 and 2024, when Tories voted in favour and Labour abstained
Yet despite Green opposition, Labour councillors’ decision to abstain on the final Budget votes have allowed the Conservatives push through their 15% Council Tax rise in 2023 and another 5% rise on top of that last year – while still cutting services.
Croydon’s Green councillors – Ria Patel and Esther Sutton – are calling on the Mayor to be honest with Croydon residents.
He needs to admit that he is yet again asking them to pay more for less.
He also needs to be honest that he isn’t “fixing the finances”, as he promised when seeking election in 2022. In fact, things are just getting worse and there is an even bigger hole in the Budget this year compared to last. This week, the government has agreed to a £136million bail-out – a record – that was requested by Perry’s council.
We all know that Croydon is massively in debt due to financial mismanagement under Conservative and Labour administrations. We have also seen a massive cut in central government funding in real terms for Croydon Council over the last 15 years. There are no signs that the new Labour government has any intention of restoring council funding to pre-2010 levels. The £136million might fill this year’s hole in Mayor Perry’s Budget, but Greens are demanding a long-term settlement to fund Croydon fairly in years to come.
Going cheap…: Heathfield House, one Victorian era Italiante villa, one careless owner, could be yours for just £1m for a 125-year lease
Mayor Perry still can’t make his sums add up and so is asking for permission to sell off even more of our council assets to fill the holes in his budget. He is being encouraged to do this by the government-appointed improvement panel, which is looking at possibly selling off any properties they can, including the Fairfield Halls and Heathfield House, announced this week as being up for auction on a 125-year lease.
Croydon’s Greens are asking the Mayor to be honest about this and honest that selling off assets isn’t a solution to our problems. They say, “The only way Croydon is going to get out of the mess we are in is for central government to step in and significantly increase funding, write-off large amounts of the debt, or preferably both.”
Until then, the Greens are also calling Mayor Perry to be fairer in the way cuts are made.
The Mayor’s Budget currently proposes giving himself and senior Conservative and Labour councillors a pay rise. Under his own proposals, Mayor Perry’s salary will go up to £84,000 per year.
Croydon’s Greens say, “It is completely wrong for senior members of the council to be giving themselves a pay rise while they are sacking front-line staff and reducing the services we get from our council.”
Councillor Patel has already voiced frustration at the incredibly slow and ineffective system being used to re-write the council’s constitution. Conservatives and Labour have worked together to keep the old two-party cabinet system – paying themselves Special Responsibility Allowances for both cabinet and shadow cabinet roles, even though those roles no longer do anything.
The Greens are calling for these cabinet and shadow cabinet posts to be removed from the council constitution. And they have repeated their call from last year to cut the Special Responsibility Allowances by 50%.
Greens are also applying the same principle to senior members of staff at the council. “Croydon Council is delivering fewer services for residents… however, since 2022 the total pay for senior officials has increased.” ONe proposal is for the pay for the council chief executive to be increased by almost £12,000, to £204,000 per year.
Green vision: Fairfield councillors Esther Sutton (left) and Ria Patel (right) will be proposing pay cuts for cabinet members and council directors, as article author Peter Underwood explains
The Greens are calling for a pay freeze for council officials already on salaries of £100,000 per year or more, as well as a reduction in the number of those senior directors over coming months.
Croydon’s Greens want the savings from these cuts to councillors’ SRAs and executive directors at the council to be ploughed back into frontline services.
They want to use the money to help restore the youth services that the Mayor has just cut.
Greens also want to put more resources in to helping residents in other areas, like advice for private renters and those struggling with debts, and more work to reduce violence against women and girls.
Last year, both Conservative and Labour councillors voted against the plan to cut their allowances but let the Mayor’s tax rises and cuts to jobs and services go through.
We will find out soon whether they vote against the Greens’ proposals again this year.
- Peter Underwood was the Green Party’s candidate for Croydon Mayor in 2022, and is a well-known figure locally for his work with environmental charities and political campaigning
Croydon Commentary provides a platform for any of our readers to offer their personal views about what matters to them in and around our corner of south London. To submit an article for publication, just email us at inside.croydon@btinternet.com, or post your comment to an Inside Croydon article that has caught your attention
Recent Croydon Commentaries
- Council computer errors and £195 driving fine that never was
- ‘The improvement panel’s general position is to sell everything’
- Westfield need to rebuild their Croydon credibility before all else
- Death of the high street (Part 94): now even estate agents exit
- Inside Croydon has moved to Bluesky. Click here to join us there for latest updates and insights
Check out our archive of podcasts on Spotify, including our monthly news discussion panel show thingy, the Croydon Insider, and The Andrew Fisher Interview
FREE ADS: Paid-up subscribers to Inside Croydon qualify for a free ad for their business, residents’ association or community group, just one of the benefits of being part of our online community. For more information about being an iC subscriber, click here for our Patreon page
PAID ADS: To advertise your services or products to our 10,000 weekday visitors to the site, as featured on Google News Showcase, email us inside.croydon@btinternet.com for our unbeatable ad rates
- If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, or want to publicise your residents’ association or business, or if you have a local event to promote, please email us with full details at inside.croydon@btinternet.com
As featured on Google News Showcase
- Our comments section on every report provides all readers with an immediate “right of reply” on all our content. Our comments policy can be read by clicking here
Inside Croydon is a member of the Independent Community News Network
Yes 1000% Cut all Croydon cabinets members
Earnings by 60%. So poorer citizens don’t suffer
And have to pay COUNCIL TAX. if they don’t
Acceptable than they know where door is opened
It let them walk off. We can run better than them.
Before taking his wholly undeserved £84k, part-time Perry should tell us how many hours he puts in for the money we pay him. Same goes for his Cabinet Members, and for Labour’s Shadow Cabinet
Shouldn’t we judge him on his achievements? He’s delivered the government bail-out and …
Perry’s ripping out the bidet from his en-suite. He’s installing you instead
closed four libraries, with others under threat !
You count insolvency as his acheivement. What’s the other one then or is it just a …?
This week’s “bailout” isn’t money from the Govt, it’s permission to dig a deeper hole.
This man Perry must go!
Even if Mayor Perry worked for free 5 years at £84k is £420k, which is still a rounding error in the council’s finances. More radical solutions are needed.
I would welcome paying politicians *more*, but prohibiting second jobs. This would hopefully give more equity to encourage the best candidates (regardless of their personal finances), full value from their time and energy, and reduced conflicts of interest. Perhaps particularly valuable in Croydon, given Perry’s ‘part time’ moniker…
It’s not just £84k Chris. Add on nearly £12k in Employer’s National Insurance Contributions and you’ll find that part-time Perry will cost us almost £100k a year – and for what?
If he, his Tory “Cabinet” and the Labour front bench were serious about fixing the finances, they’d all forego their special responsibility allowances and instead only take the newly increased councillor’s basic allowance of £11,984 a year. That would save around £531k annually, (plus the afore-mentioned NICs).
The two Greens and one LibDem make do on the basic £11,984 as do 33 Labour and Tory backbenchers. Why not the pigs with their snouts in the council trough? Let’s face it, with a part-time Mayor and a borough being run by the government and council officers, the extra dosh is a reward for the greedy, who in truth have no “special responsibilities”
It’s nice to imagine local politicians would do a great job for free, out of the goodness of their hearts. But I fear you pay peanuts and get monkeys.
Whilst it’s galling the pay of senior management and cabinet members given the poor performance of the council, demanding government to give Croydon isn’t a solution because they don’t have to, unfortunately a council isn’t in a position to make demands to the government. That’s the premise of this article and not to reward failure, which is a fair point. The Mayor certainly could be more vocal, or just say anything at all on the funding issue. Perry comes out with enough videos and yet never says anything useful in any of them, just mainly highlighting the most basic things a council should be doing anyway. It would be pleasing to see a Mayor vocally butting heads with government about funding and have a running commentary on the situation, it might not achieve any more funding but it would be good to see someone actually fighting a little for the right thing and showing that they care.
It will never change, he never replies to emails. Just rude 😡