There has been an outpouring of anger at the news, first reported by this website, that ‘the Scrooges of Westfield’ have ordered Bishops Wine Bar to move out of their home of more than 40 years
Outpouring of support: regulars at Bishops Wine Bar, run by Angela Ferrara (behind the bar), have been furious at the decision to terminate the business’s lease in June
The latest closure of a Croydon business ordered by the management of the Whitgift Centre has provoked an angry public backlash – from regular tipplers at Bishops’ Wine Bar but also from some who assumed the bar had closed long ago, and others who never even knew it existed.
Inside Croydon reported on Friday how Angela Ferrara, Bishops’ manager, had posted an online public petition after her business had been served notice to quit by the end of June this year. She called the decision “arbitrary and unjust”. Ferrara has told Inside Croydon that almost a week since the unwelcome notice arrived on New Year’s Eve, she has still received no explanation for the decision to exercise the break clause in the wine bar’s lease.
And the news has drawn strong criticism of Westfield, the multibillion multinational property giant, now based in Paris, which manages the Whitgift Centre.
There has also been an outpouring of messages of support for the wine bar’s managers.
“Bishops Wine Bar is part of what makes Croydon…Croydon,” said one petition signatory.
“It’s a warm and cosy little place with a long history and a unique character. Croydon needs such places. I can understand that if the Westfield development is actually going ahead (who believes this?!) then, yeah, such a closure is inevitable.
“But if that really is the case, there needs to be a suitable replacement venue for Angela, Cosimo and the unique character of Bishops Wine Bar to continue. Surely there is a solution here? Please lets not rip out any more of the soul of Croydon.”
Doubling up: the Bishops petition (using an image of another wine bar) has more than doubled its signatures since the iC article appeared last Friday
Westfield has been promising a £1billion regeneration of Croydon town centre for 14 years, without ever delivering on their promises. In one iteration of their plans, tenant businesses in the Whitgift Centre were to be offered alternative premises in Centrale, the other large (and increasingly empty) shopping mall on the opposite side of North End.
Westfield were supposed to submit an updated planning application – their third – by November 2024. That date slipped to November 2025. Now, no new planning application is expected from Westfield until the early summer, at the earliest.
There has been no alternative premises offer for Bishops, while the exodus of traders from the Whitgift Centre appears to be gathering pace.
After a decade and a half of devastating development blight inflicted on the once bustling and vibrant town centre by Westfield, the developers and their cheerleaders, such as Croydon’s part-time Mayor Jason Perry, have recently celebrated the opening of six kiosks where the Allders department store used to be.
Bishops, nestled in a hard-to-find corner of the increasingly desolate shopping centre, has been enduring an existential battle for a couple of years, especially so since the Whitgift Centre management closed the Allders multi-storey car park in 2024, cutting off the wine bar from anyone in the shopping mall who might fancy a swift Malbec before lugging their shopping home.
Recently, the shopping centre managers have even been dubbed “the Scrooges of Westfield”, after they blocked a local choir from singing carols and raising money for charity in the centre at Christmas time.
No sign of business: the Whitgift Centre’s promised signage for Bishops Wine Bar has never materialised
The move on Bishops has not won Westfield any new admirers. On social media platforms, iC readers responded with a mixture of anger, and some bemusement.
“I’m now getting a sense that Westfield and Croydon Council may be bullying units out in order to turn [the shopping centre] into flats… This now makes so much sense. A lack of businesses framed as an organic lack of interest will be used to justify it,” one reader suggested.
In fact, the area’s future was outlined in a “masterplan” drawn up by Westfield last year, which proposes building 3,000 flats where the Whitgift Centre stands today, and getting rid of two-thirds of the retail space in the town centre – something which Croydon Mayor Jason Perry has gone along with.
Another reader asked: “What is the answer to the decline of Croydon, its bars shops and vibe?
“It was a go-to town in its day. Dr Jim’s , Scamps, The Market, rammed on Saturday morning, decent shops, Grants, Allders, Debenhams. All gone.
“How the fuck can the town recover and get back on track, repair the crack ripping it apart?”
When Mayor Perry’s name was mentioned as someone who could intervene on behalf of Bishops, one loyal reader said that he “will hide and do or say nothing in support of Bishops”.
Hidden gem: Bishop’s Wine Bar, one of the few remaining businesses in the shopping centre, has an uncertain future
One reader summed up many other comments about Bishops: “A classy little drinking establishment hidden in the Whitgift centre. Sad it’s closing.”
Others expressed their surprise that the place might be closed: “No way! My boss was always in there many years ago,” they said.
The difficulties in locating Bishops and its out-of-the-way location was reflected in several other comments. “I thought that had closed years ago. I haven’t been in there for at least 20 years or so,” one said.
“Been in Croydon 10 years but didn’t know this place even existed. Will be sure to visit now!”
“Where is it?” asked more than one.
Ferrara, confirming that Westfield and the Whitgift Centre management had yet to provide any explanation for their decision, told Inside Croydon: “We have been overwhelmed by the goodwill and support for Bishops that our petition has gained and would like to thank everyone who has signed it.
“The situation is baffling and massively stressful to us.”
Read more: The MP hidden away on third floor of a deserted shopping mall
Read more: Town centre traders struggle on to serve up the good times
Read more: Another Whitgift store to close – and manager blames Westfield
PAID ADS: To advertise your services or products to our 10,000 weekday visitors to the site, as featured on Google News Showcase, email us inside.croydon@btinternet.com for our unbeatable ad rates
- If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, or want to publicise your residents’ association or business, or if you have a local event to promote, please email us with full details at inside.croydon@btinternet.com
As featured on Google News Showcase
- Our comments section on every report provides all readers with an immediate “right of reply” on all our content. Our comments policy can be read by clicking here
Inside Croydon is a founder member of the Independent Community News Network
Hello Inside Croydon
Thanks for the great investigations and articles. I have a couple of items that I wonder if you would follow up?
1. Have you investigated whether the new shops in Allders are subsidised and, if so, by whom?
2. Regarding the issue with Bishops, it would be interesting to see the annual levels of receipts of business rates for the Whitgift Centre for the last 12 years. One would hope that the landlord paid on all the empty properties.
I’ll be sad to see Bishop’s go, mainly because it’s an anachronism – a fossilised reminder of what wine bars were like in the ‘sixties. Only the clientele and the prawn cocktails have aged! All assuming you can find it, of course
Oh dear where will all the sad lushes wash up? So sad that the haven of lost souls and sad losers has to close. Boo hoo.
Bishops Wine Bar (hopefully the Google maps pin is correctly located)
Unit 1129 Whitgift Centre, Croydon CR0 1UZ
51.37507, -0.09942
///toys.rush.parade
TQ323657
TQ 32380 65716
51°22′30″N , 000°05′58″W
532380, 165716
Visit them 🙂
Surely the Whitgift Centre have other empty units with zero footfall that they could offer them? Maybe they could move into the old Superdry store and rebrand it “The Forum”?
There’s nothing wrong with the existing premises. What URW want is to get rid of everybody so they can knock the whole place down
That much has been established ever since Westfield got the Compulsory Purchase Order seven or eight years ago (and paid for by Croydon Council). And that ought not be an issue if they fulfilled the promise of offering relocation to Centrale, which they have not.
And there is no current planning permission. With no planning application expected before the end of May, there’s little prospect of any demolition work beginning before 2028, at the earliest. So there is no immediate need to force traders out – leaving the shopping centre empty for more than two years.
The problem with Centrale as a pub location is they close at 7pm. Harry’s may be out the way a bit but you can still get into it after 8pm. My joke was that when originally built the open air Whitgift had a pub (the Forum) at it’s center. When it became a retail palace and was covered over, the bar was removed as too seedy and also now the complex had doors that needed to close at 7pm it was a useless location for anyone running a nighttime economy business as it was closed at night now…. I asked Gavin Barwell years ago why they wanted to knock down a shopping centre to build a shopping centre and one of the answers he gave is the current design completely cuts the Whitgift off at night, turning it into an “impenetrable fortress in the middle of the town after 8pm”. Politicians might find the night time economy grubby and the home of sad old lushes but the Whitgift shows what happens when you sever the nighttime economy from retail. I wonder how all this fits with Kemi’s new campaign to “save the pub as the heart of a village”
Bishops closes at 7pm.
Didn’t know it existed. Would love to be able to go out in Croydon of a night but too few pubs/bars/night clubs to make it appealing. A whole section of the Whitgift centre could be turned into bars/clubs.