Tory needed Fraud Office permission to stand in election

Our political editor, WALTER CRONXITE, on the real agenda behind one of the council by-elections next month

Sonia Marinello: the Tory candidate photographed on her visit to South Norwood

Croydon Conservatives are so confident of losing the South Norwood council by-election next month that they have fielded a candidate whose job might prevent her from becoming a local councillor.

It is being seen as a cynical ploy by the local Tories, which one South Norwood resident told Inside Croydon, “treats residents, even Conservative Party members and their activists, with utter contempt”.

The resident added, “It also shows what the Conservatives really think of the democratic process.”

The deviousness and deceit began when the Tories announced their by-election candidates earlier this month, describing Sonia Marinello as “a South Norwood supporter”.

“That’s intended for the unwary to assume Marinello lives in South Norwood. She does not, otherwise the Tories would have said so,” said a Tory Party insider.

“After all, what does ‘South Norwood supporter‘ actually mean? It’s nothing, vacuousness intended to pull the wool over people’s eyes.”

Tory candidate Marinello has declared herself as being against this Tory government policy

Marinello has withheld her home address from the declarations published by the council, a strategy which is often used by properly qualified candidates who wish to disguise that they are not as “local” to the ward which they are contesting as they would like voters to assume.

Our mole outside Croydon Tories’ HQ in Purley suggests that the choice of Marinello is another piece of arch-cynicism, as the Conservatives seek to capitalise on opposition to the local traffic networks which have been introduced by the Labour-controlled council in Upper Norwood and South Norwood.

Croydon Tories describe Marinello as “helping to lead the charge against the deeply unpopular Low Traffic Neighbourhoods”.

What they really mean is that Marinello has been a lead player in the Open Our Roads campaign. This week, the founder of the supposedly apolitical residents’ group ordered its supporters to vote for Marinello in the South Norwood by-election.

Grant Shapps: Tory minister behind LTNs policy

Of course, LTNs are a traffic-reducing policy from the Tory government, and were introduced across London thanks to millions of pounds of funding from Conservative transport minister Grant Shapps – not that you’ll find that anywhere on the Tory election bumpf being forced through your letterboxes in the next couple of weeks.

The truth is, Croydon Tories, and even Marinello if pressed, realise that it would take a 27per cent swing from Labour to the Conservatives to win the South Norwood seat.

The Conservatives have not won a council seat in South Norwood since 2006.

In 2018, South Norwood was the second worst-performing ward for the Conservatives across the whole of Croydon at the last borough-wide Town Hall elections. Then, the Tories received just 15.8 per cent of the vote, as South Norwood returned three Labour councillors. Labour scored 69.6 per cent of the vote.

Which means that there’s very little risk of Marinello having to give up her high-powered Whitehall job as a case controller with the Serious Fraud Office come May 7.

Cockspur Street will be Marinello’s head office for some time yet

In their public announcement of candidates, Croydon Tories had described Marinello, a former pupil at Clapham’s La Retraite Catholic girls’ school, as being “an investigative lawyer by day”.

In Marinello’s own profiles on social media, she has said that she is “a criminal investigator at the Civil Service”; they show that she has worked for the government since December 2014. It has also been published that Marinello is a case controller at the SFO.

In its public recruitment papers, the SFO describes the role of its case controllers as being “accountable for managing cases of top tier fraud, bribery and corruption… You develop the strategy… to bring successful conclusions for each case, including deciding which cases should no longer be pursued.”

SFO documents show that they pay salaries of up to £78,000 for case controllers.

It seems likely that Marinello’s job at the SFO would be regarded as “politically restricted”, a Civil Service rule which excludes public servants from seeking elected office.

Inside Croydon has now established that Marinello did seek special permission from her employers just to stand as a candidate in the by-election.

Marinello: had to get boss’s permission to stand

The SFO confirmed to Inside Croydon that, “the civil service grade as a case controller would be the equivalent of a Grade 6 or Band A”.

According to the latest government guidelines, Civil Service Grade 6 is senior enough to be regarded as politically restricted.

Inside Croydon wanted to put some questions to Marinello about this matter. Croydon Conservatives declined to give us a direct contact number to speak to their candidate, and instead provided a generic South Norwood campaign email address, possibly managed from the constituency office of Croydon South MP Chris Philp, in Purley.

An anonymous Tory flunky replied, “Permission was sought and granted from her employer prior to her selection.”

It is clear that Croydon Tories are using the by-elections in Labour strongholds as a dummy run to train potential candidates for bigger and better things, such as the 2022 local elections.

“Anyone running in Labour seats in these by-elections are being tested for safe or winnable seats next year,” our mole in the lawn outside the Tory bunker in Purley advised.

“They wouldn’t run someone knowingly in these elections if they couldn’t stand and win a marginal or safe seat next year.”

South Norwood is one of five ward by-elections being contested on May 6.

For the full list of all candidates in each ward, click here.

Read more: ‘Cynical’ Tories face backlash over bogus links to food bank
Read more: ‘Most dangerous man in Britain’ to stand in council election
Read more: Candidates’ tough task to shake off Labour reputation
Read more: Croydon Labour shaken after resignation of third councillor


  • If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, want to publicise your residents’ association or business, or if you have a local event to promote, please email us with full details at inside.croydon@btinternet.com
  • Inside Croydon is a member of the Independent Community News Network
  • Inside Croydon works together with the Bureau of Investigative Journalism and BBC London News
  • ROTTEN BOROUGH AWARDS: Croydon was named the country’s rottenest borough in 2020 in the annual round-up of civic cock-ups in Private Eye magazine – the fourth successive year that Inside Croydon has been the source for such award-winning nominations
  • Inside Croydon: 3million page views in 2020. Seen by 1.4million unique visitors

About insidecroydon

News, views and analysis about the people of Croydon, their lives and political times in the diverse and most-populated borough in London. Based in Croydon and edited by Steven Downes. To contact us, please email inside.croydon@btinternet.com
This entry was posted in Croydon Council, Jane Avis, South Norwood and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Tory needed Fraud Office permission to stand in election

  1. Croydonite says:

    Croydon Cllr Mike Fisher resigned his Grade 7 post because it breached political impartiality rules under the Civil Service code yet a more senior Civil Servant is allowed to breach the same impartiality rules?

    This just does not feel right

    Will Croydon Conservatives kindly publish the Cabinet Office permission email or letter?

  2. If Marinello is an “investigative lawyer” for a government department “accountable for managing cases of top tier fraud, bribery and corruption”, you’d think she’d be busy sinking her teeth into “Dave” Cameron, Matt Hancock and all the scumbags who’ve benefited from a billion quids worth of no-bid contracts given to people who’ve donated to the corrupt Conservative Party.

    Maybe that’s because her role includes “deciding which cases should no longer be pursued.” and asking no tough questions to begin with.

    She makes her Labour rival Louis Carserides look independent, competent and trustworthy.

Leave a Reply