According to Barwell, Starmer cost Labour the 2019 election

WALTER CRONXITE, our political editor, got his hands dirty at the weekend, in an effort to save you the uncomfortable displeasure of reading The S*n, and to save you 20 quid

For more than 30 years, families on Merseyside and Liverpool Football Club supporters around the world have supported the Don’t Buy The S*n campaign, following the Murdoch tabloid’s terrible, spiteful and unfounded coverage of the last moments of loved ones at the 1989 Hillsborough disaster. The newspaper’s sales in the city have never recovered.

That doesn’t appear to have bothered “Lord” Gavin Barwell, the former Croydon Central MP who was brought up in south London but who claims to be an avid Liverpool football fan.

For Barwell allowed his latest book to be serialised at the weekend by The S*n, very possibly after the biggest payers of serialisation rights on what was once Fleet Street, the Sunday Times and Daily Mail, rejected his latest memoir, Chief Of Staff: Notes From Downing Street.

Those foolish enough not to have resisted the temptation to read Barwell’s previous straight-to-the-remainder-bins classic, How To Lose A Marginal Seat, will probably understand the reasons that his latest offering wound up with a downmarket taboid. It is actually not very good.

The exposure in The S*n makes that very clear.

If you were expecting revelations from Barwell’s time at the heart of government, working as Prime Minister Theresa May’s top adviser, then you will be disappointed. Perhaps it is the Official Secrets Act – which Barwell will have signed – or perhaps he’s just not a very good diarist, but if the extracts unveiled at the weekend are anything to go by, then anyone who does buy the book when it is published later this week is in for 432 very dull pages.

The newspaper extracts, after all, are supposed to be the best bits.

Barwell with his boss, Theresa Mayhem: did she know he wrote books?

Yet what appeared over the weekend tended all to be already well-known episodes in May’s unhappy two years in Downing Street. Doubtless, she might have been happier, and had more success, had she been wiser in her selection of advisers.

The book’s title has been adjusted since Barwell signed his deal with publishers Atlantic. Chief of Staff: My Time as the Prime Minister’s Right-Hand Man was probably deemed just a tad too onanistic, even for the man who was caught responding to porn sites while working late into the night at No10.

The cover will undoubtedly play to the vanity and West Wing-style delusions of grandeur of the author, as he flicks through the pages while in one of the House of Lords’ tea rooms the next time he collects his £305 per diem just for showing up.

Those who doubt Keir Starmer’s abilities to revive the fortunes of Labour won’t be surprised to learn from the book that he was to blame for his party’s 2019 General Election defeat. Barwell says that it was Starmer’s “colossal misjudgment” to block his party from supporting a compromise over Brexit.

It was Barwell’s task, when at No10, to steer through a programme that would deliver Brexit. That he failed sees him seeking others to blame

According to Barwell, Starmer even attacked proposals that he himself had put forward.

May was so desperate to get any form of Brexit deal through parliament in the dying days of her premiership that she opened negotiations to Jeremy Corbyn’s Labour Party.

“Jeremy Corbyn wanted to do it, but Keir Starmer stopped it,” Barwell says in his book.

“Starmer was not prepared to settle for anything that didn’t include a confirmatory vote.”

In other revelations right up there with bears shitting in the woods and Popes generally being of the Catholic persuasion, Barwell’s book tells us that his old mate Boris Johnson was “gaffe-prone” and not on top of his brief.

“On one occasion, he blurted out to me: ‘You don’t like Brexit because you blame it and me for losing your seat’.

“I was taken aback. It was true that I hadn’t wanted the UK to leave the EU, but whatever my personal views, I accepted our obligation to implement the will of the people.”

Elsewhere, Barwell also “reveals” that Theresa May had no idea of how to play pool (shock!), and that on one flight back from an international conference, she had beer spilt over her by another aide (horror!).

Boris Johnson: Gaffe-prone, according to Barwell. Who’d have guessed?

Oh, and in his book, Barwell goes to some lengths to explain that Gavin Williamson is a prize twat.

If what was published at the weekend really are the plum pieces available after Barwell spent almost as long writing up his memoir as the time he spent as No10’s Chief of Staff, then the book is thin gruel indeed (we have not had the advantage of the usual media review copy, possibly because the publishers are a little sensitive after the warm welcome we gave to Barwell’s previous lacklustre efforts).

Thus it is that the behind-closed-doors wheeling and dealing with Labour over Brexit appear the most insightful parts of his unreliable memoir.

“The Prime Minister met with Jeremy Corbyn and Sir Keir Starmer, then the shadow Brexit minister, and asked them whether Labour might be prepared to support the withdrawal agreement only,” Barwell writes. “Keir replied that they could only do that if there was agreement on the future relationship and a second referendum.

Keir Starmer: Brexit dropped bollocks

“’Couldn’t those issues be sorted out during the passage of the Withdrawal Agreement Bill?’ I asked.

“No, he said, because we would have left by then.

“I was stunned that he did not understand the basic fact that we would not have left until the Withdrawal Agreement Bill had been passed.”

Barwell goes on to describe a meeting with the Labour leadership held on May 6, where he claims that Starmer “objected to the language on customs” used  in one of the bilateral documents. “I pointed out that we had lifted it from his letter of April 22 — he was objecting to his own policy,” Barwell writes.

Once the talks broke down, Barwell writes, “Labour didn’t have any confidence that whoever succeeded her would abide by any deal, and it was pretty clear Keir was not prepared to settle for anything that didn’t include a commitment to a confirmatory vote.

“I’m not sure whether the Shadow Cabinet realised at the time, but they had killed off the last chance for a compromise Brexit…

“Jeremy Corbyn wanted to do it, but Keir Starmer stopped it. It seems fitting he’s now dealing with the consequences.”

  • For the avoidance of any doubt, no copies of The S*n were bought in the compilation of this review

Read more: Barwell’s Downing Street book is promising ‘revelations’

  • If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, or want to publicise your residents’ association or business, or if you have a local event to promote, please email us with full details at
  • Inside Croydon is a member of the Independent Community News Network
  • Inside Croydon works together with the Bureau of Investigative Journalism, as well as BBC London News and ITV London
  • ROTTEN BOROUGH AWARDS: Croydon was named the country’s rottenest borough in 2020 in the annual round-up of civic cock-ups in Private Eye magazine – the fourth successive year that Inside Croydon has been the source for such award-winning nominations
  • Inside Croydon: 3million page views in 2020. Seen by 1.4million unique visitors

About insidecroydon

News, views and analysis about the people of Croydon, their lives and political times in the diverse and most-populated borough in London. Based in Croydon and edited by Steven Downes. To contact us, please email
This entry was posted in 2019 General Election, Gavin Barwell and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to According to Barwell, Starmer cost Labour the 2019 election

  1. Of course a second referendum makes absolute sense, especially now people have experienced many of the effects of Brexit and its insanity. It is a pity that May did not hold out for such a democratic process.

  2. No doubt the noble Lord has self-redacted his less than noble part in the tragedy of Grenfall Tower in his book?

  3. Nick Davies says:

    Did Lord Whitgift actually write it, or was it ghosted by “Super” Mario?

  4. Lewis White says:

    In the picture, I saw the magic words “Downing Street” and saw the suit, tie and receding hairline in the picture, and–yes– for more than a moment–wondered if this could be a picture of a thoughtfully reflective down-ward looking, humble, still youthful, statesman Tony Blair PM a few years back?

    Could it be that Lord Gav, having achieved so much already, such as being a Croydon Councillor, , winning a safe Tory seat,(and being a Minister), then losing it, then, in spite of all, landing a plum job with a PM, then getting elevated to the Lords….. could it just be that having dissed the current leader of the Labour Party, that Lord G might cross the House to join the benches opposite ??

    Might relinquish his L’dship, and run for Labour Leader and become a future PM?

Leave a Reply