Locals living near Selhurst Park have organised to oppose the new stand – despite being frozen out of meetings by their Labour councillors
Two residents’ associations in the area around Selhurst Park, together with council tenants whose homes are under threat of demolition, have joined forces to oppose the £100million new stand being proposed by Crystal Palace Football Club.
Campaign leaflets: residents are spreading their opposition to the £100m planned new stand at Selhurst Park
Frozen out of meetings by their own elected councillors, residents of Rothesay Road, Farnley Road and Wooderson Close, together with the Holmesdale Residents’ Association and Pembroke Road RA, held their own meeting last week at which they agreed to show a red card to the Palace redevelopment.
Leaflets being distributed in the area claim that only eight full-time jobs will be created in Croydon by the new stand. “The local community deserves more,” the leaflet states.
They also reckon that the new stand, with its emphasis on corporate hospitality boxes, is aimed at “the prawn sandwich brigade”, offering little for season ticket-holders and regular Eagles fans.
“The design is brilliant at celebrating arrival to the ground, but… all the focus is on corporate hospitality, looking away from the pitch and on to private homes [and] gardens.
“You the fans deserve a better stadium, let’s… give this application the red card!”
The residents criticise the scheme’s scale and massing. The gargantuan new stand, in an area of two-storey houses, will be seven storeys high – the original application four years ago claimed that the building would be five storeys.
No answer: Louis Carserides (right) with his boss, Croydon North MP Steve Reed OBE
They also say that the stand would cause light pollution and issues with glare, and it would overlook neighbouring properties. At least, it would overlook those neighbouring properties that don’t get bulldozed to make way for the development.
In a paper prepared for the residents by a local architect, the demolition of at least five houses on Wooderson Close is compared to the homes destroyed in Mariupol in Ukraine by invading Russian forces.
Those living in houses neighbouring Selhurst Park, some of whom have been living in limbo and uncertainty for nearly five years, are not convinced by the club’s offer to pay for new homes to be built.
“London is in the middle of a housing crisis,” they say.
“Selling off assets and relocating long-term residents who have lived in the area for over 30 years is not only adding to the problem, it is also a betrayal of trust.”
The residents also claim that they have been deliberately shut out of the consultation process by their own Labour councillors in South Norwood ward, who they believe are working closely with lobbyists for the football club.
Palace’s new stand, which will add nearly 10,000 seats to the stadium, was first granted planning permission by Croydon Council in 2018. But the development stalled and the club failed to sign an important agreement undertaking to rehome the residents of five houses on Wooderson Close that would have to be demolished to make way for the massive new structure.
Palace have this summer submitted a revised planning application. It is expected to be brought before the planning committee next month.
But specially hired lobbyists have refused to allow the affected residents to attend their meetings with councillors. And now the councillors have been accused of holding their own “secretive” meetings with council directors to discuss the plans, without any proper engagement with the affected residents.
Tall storeys: residents’ objections show how the seven-storey building will dominate neighbouring residents’ homes
It is understood that the councillors involved are Louis Carserides and Christopher Herman, both of whom have day jobs working for Labour MPs.
Carserides works in the Westminster office of Croydon North MP, Steve Reed OBE, who in late 2021 was wined and dined by Peter Bingle, the founder of the Terrapin Group.
It is the same Terrapin Group that has been hired as lobbyists by Crystal Palace.
Residents’ letters to the councillors over their behind-closed-doors meetings with Terrapin and with council planners have failed to receive any response.
No answer: Labour councillor Christopher Herman has failed to reply to residents’ emails expressing concern about the stadium scheme
In their leaflets and submissions to the council’s planning department, the coalition of Selhurst and South Norwood residents say, “As neighbours, we are sympathetic to the needs of the football club”, but they say that Palace “have prioritised the need for growth and profits over their neighbours and… they are willing to make long-standing members of the community homeless and displaced”.
They claim that in 2018, the planning committee concluded that the size of the scale of the stand is disproportionate to the low-rise housing in the surrounding streets.
“Loose arguments around the broader economic benefits and commercial viability for the club are noted but none of design excellence, which is the usual minimum for a project of this scale .
“The proposed building is far from memorable, bold or iconic. It is so bland and generic… [it] could be mistaken for an airport, a shopping centre or office block. The only bold element is the mass and scale of building when considered against the neighbouring local properties.
“Aside from potentially diluting the footballing experience with the ‘prawn sandwich brigade’ the main issue with the hospitality and supporting balconies is the issue of overlooking Clifton Road, Wooderson Close and Holmesdale Road.”
Read more: Residents blocked from meeting by football club’s lobbyists
Read more: Consultation on Selhurst new stand is extended by two weeks
Read more: ‘Abrasive’ lobbyist smoothing the way for Selhurst’s new stand
- If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, or want to publicise your residents’ association or business, or if you have a local event to promote, please email us with full details at inside.croydon@btinternet.com
Inside Croydon is a member of the Independent Community News Network- By having a comment section, we provide all readers with an immediate “right of reply” on all our content. Details of how this works can be read by clicking here
- Inside Croydon works together with the Bureau of Investigative Journalism, as well as BBC London News and ITV London
- Inside Croydon: 3.3million page views in 2021. Seen by 1.6million unique visitors in that 12-month period
This is never going to be built lets stop this crap and build a new stadium in the park. This should have happened years ago plenty of transport and room, make it happen.
I’m shocked, Crystal Palace Park is not big enough for the stadium they’ve suggested. Plus it’s a precious green space for all members of the public. We really need to preserve these places and the nature within them for the public not a commercial purpose like football.
It’s plenty big enough. There’s a stadium there already. Indeed, the stadium was at the centre of the club’s previous plans to re-locate there.
The club has looked into building a stadium in CPP but it was instantly rejected by local residents. Moving the stadium to the park will never happen, so expanding Selhurst Park is the only option.
What Steve Parish said when he abandoned the possibility of moving to the stadium site in Crystal Palace Park was all because of the red tape and barriers put up to the scheme by the Mayor of London at that time, Boris Johnson.
For CPFC to be in the premiership is commendable, HOWEVER Selhurst Park is scarcely the place for the Stadium they deserve, and given the run down nature of Crystal Palace Park it would seem the logical pace to move it to. However, in doing so it would move it into LB Bromley thus potentially have a major impact on LBC !!
If I recall The Park may well have been within another borough perhaps even Croydon !! Given the Crystal Palace was once in Regents Park perhaps it could move there ?? I Jest !!
If I recall, when the Palace was moved to Sydenham it had it’s own stadium, look here;-
https://historicengland.org.uk/listing/the-list/list-entry/1000373?section=comments-and-photos
and here
https://www.ideal-homes.org.uk/__data/assets/image/0003/304446/01327-2000.jpg
Where the Great Fountains once were ??? and where the athletics track and sports centre are now ??
Given COVID and the harsh economic crisis we are entering is it really prudent to build this massive stadium which will have a huge knock on effect on local resident with the extra thousands of supporters arriving by public transport and on foot. I can recall the area being gridlocked on match days, with associated problems occurring on a regular basis.
Such a shame Crystal Palace High Level Station has gone, otherwise The Park may have been an ideal site. The low level station is poorly served by ‘slow trains’ and a convoluted route.
At one time the tram was to be extended, however that never happened, however the ‘Bus Stand’ still exists on ‘The Parade’, and there is Penge West Station to the south.
Oh to wind back the clock as the Victorians had so much right.
The Great Exhibition of 1851 was in Hyde Park.