KEN LEE, our Town Hall reporter, on the Mayor’s latest ‘short-sighted short-termism’ that will yet again see residents paying more to get less
In the red: Purley Nursery is among the five council-run schools whose future is under review
Jason Perry, the Conservative Mayor of Croydon who put up the borough’s Council Tax by 15per cent in April, now wants to close or merge five nursery schools run by the council.
The proposals are in a paper expected to be nodded through by Perry’s pliant Tory councillors at Wednesday night’s cabinet meeting.
Under Perry, the council is moving to reduce early years education provision in Croydon just weeks after Chancellor Jeremy Hunt announced that the government will be increasing early-years education provision – which will probably (Croydon Council says it doesn’t yet know) increase the need for places at nursery schools.
The council says that the cuts are necessary because of “cumulative deficit across the… estate is £560,760 (as of end of previous year)”.
Ignoring the imminent increase in demand for nursery places, Piss-poor Perry said, “This has been an issue for many, many years and we’ve now got to make decisions around this.
“The five schools overall aren’t sustainable and this is the opening of that conversation, making sure the future is sustainable.”
The nursery schools under threat are:
- Thornton Heath Nursery (Ofsted rating: Good);
- Crosfield Nursery, South Norwood (Good);
- Selhurst Nursery (Requires improvement);
- Tunstall Nursery, Addiscombe (Outstanding);
- and Purley Nursery (Outstanding).
According to the council report: “Four of the five [Maintained Nursery Schools] are unable to balance their budget and have an increasing deficit.
“Under Section 7 of the Childcare Act 2006, Croydon has a statutory duty to provide sufficient funded three- and four-year-old places for eligible children to access.
“Early education is not statutory and is a parental choice. However, having enough and diversity of early years provision allow parents/carers to find childcare that meets their child’s learning needs and enables parents to make a real choice about work and training.”
The council report says “there are approximately 27,372 children under the age of five who are resident in Croydon.” The council report says that the five maintained nursery schools currently provide a grand total of 281 places.
“There is sufficient and diverse supply of early education and childcare provision available across the borough to meet demand,” the council report says.
The report was published on the council website last week, without any advance notice of the decision under consideration being given to the Town Hall Labour group, which has more councillors than any other political group.
The Tory councillors in Perry’s cabinet are expected to agree to recommend that the proposals should be put out to a highly skewed public consultation, and they will then ignore the findings and – probably – close at least one of the nurseries (Clue: it won’t be the one in the Tory-voting south of the borough).
Parents and local community workers expressed their shock and despair at Mayor Perry’s latest piece of dunderhead decision-making.
One parent told Inside Croydon: “This is short-sighted short-termism that will cost Croydon in the long-term. The size of the saving isn’t worth the loss of provision likely to occur.
“The only function of this is to reduce costs, as these maintained nursery schools are in deficit across the country. Maintained nurseries are a bit of an oddity these days, but they do provide a valuable service, particularly to poorer areas.
Under scrutiny: Selhurst Nursery is another of the five which the Mayor wants to merge or close
“The logic used to suggest that a falling birth rate means that these centres won’t be needed is daft, firstly because there’s currently pressure on places, secondly because cost of living issues are forcing more parents back to work earlier, and thirdly because there’s almost unanimous agreement in parliament that free provision should be increased, which will increase demand.
“Increased demand with a reduction in places will see some parents unable to find nearby provision, and everyone paying more for the ‘extra bits’ of nursery care, given that government funding does a bad job of covering costs.”
The South Norwood Community Kitchen is just around the corner from Crosfield Nursery on Elborough Road, and many parents drop in during the week.
Emma Gardiner, one of the kitchen managers, told Inside Croydon, “Maintained Nursery Schools are one of the most important assets to a community, especially in a borough like Croydon with so mahy families working hard to escape this state-generated trap of poverty and disadvantage that we struggle to live in.
“There is endless evidence for the benefits of early years provision.
“To be honest, we’re sick of stating the obvious. Many SNCK families are limited by Croydon Council and the Conservative government’s constant attack on the basics needed to survive, let alone to flourish.
“Taking away Mantained Nursery Schools is another brutal blow, and yet more evidence of Croydon Council’s disdain for its residents.”
- Inside Croydon – as seen on TV! – has been delivering local community news since 2010. 3million page views per year in 2020, 2021 and 2022.
- If you want real journalism, actually based in the borough, you should consider paying for it. Please sign up today. Click here for more details
- If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, or want to publicise your residents’ association or business, or if you have a local event to promote, please email us with full details at inside.croydon@btinternet.com
As featured on Google News Showcase
- Our comments section on every report provides all readers with an immediate “right of reply” on all our content
Inside Croydon is a member of the Independent Community News Network
- Inside Croydon works together with the Bureau of Investigative Journalism, as well as BBC London News and ITV London
ROTTEN BOROUGH AWARDS: Croydon was named among the country’s rottenest boroughs for a SIXTH successive year in 2022 in the annual round-up of civic cock-ups in Private Eye magazine
So Part time is searching for easy solutions to his problems.
Who easier to push around than the perpetually under pressure education sector. Something he would never put in his election manifesto.
The fall in numbers this London age group has been known to be coming for sometime, but this is complicated by Hunt in the Treasury claiming there is going to be a huge increase in supply of childcare support for parents.
Further under the tax avoiding Zahawi it was stated that all state schools were going to be required by the end of this decade to become academies, but not so much has been heard about that for the last 18 months or so.
It seems there is an easier solution that the tub of lard is incentivising with this ultimatum. That is to immediately become independent academies or more likely to come under the shelter of another academy chain taking the nurseries out of local Government funding and into the Dept. of Education’s direct funding or even more unlikely to become private companies contracting to provide nursery services. Perhaps pragmatic for Lardy Boy, but more unwelcome change and demands for a hard pressed sector facing perpetual budgetary pressure under this appalling Regime.
Considering that Sunak has clearly indicated that education is paramount to Great Britain developing after Brexit, clearly Perry is not a Sunak party person.
Maybe that is why Gove gave him the quivering middle digit.
This is all about slimming down and cutting costs. All areas that are running at deficit and unable to balance a budget (which is mostly everything in Croydon now that relies on Council funding) face the same. Many services not so Statutory or directly accountable ie charities etc have already closed or are closing or have slimmed back provision that assisted this Council with their Statutory duties.
By the rationale Perry and this Council are unable to balance their budget and run at the biggest deficit in local Administration History.
Would it not be better to stop screwing up everything it touches and administer the sword to itself?
Croydon has a statutory duty to consult on many things but it also has a standard non mandatory duty to take the views of all section of the population into account.
In many arenas that are regulated consultation has to be meaningful. This shower repeatedly appear to have meaningless, shortened or no consultations.
Still a totally disreputable executive sucking the live out of babes now!
This reminds me-
Who got rid of Sure Start?
Not Cllr Perry, to be sure.
But the resulting network of centres across the UK, set up by Education, Education, Education Tony Blair was quickly and effectively dismantled by the incoming Conservatives.
A tragedy, as it helped parents in less-favoured towns and areas of the inner cities and outer suburbs alike to get useful parenting skills,. knowledge on healthy eating, childcare, education and a whole load of other things–not least of which was the mixing with other mums and dads–and grandparents. aka- Social cohesion.