The newly installed street art around the town centre has its appeal, the overtly hostile security policy in Centrale less so, says KEN TOWL
Second glance: shoppers in Croydon town centre might not have too many shops to visit, but the art’s good
It was quite a thrill to be described as “the IC1 male taking pictures with a camera phone”, reminding me of the old television series The Bill, in which the use of police ethnicity identity codes was a trope.
I had been approached, in the Centrale shopping centre, by an avatar on behalf of someone called “Control”.
It did not start well. I can be a little rash sometimes and when the security guard approached and asked, “What are you photographing?”, I said, “You!” and took his picture.
He relayed this information to “Control” and then repeated to me what “Control” was saying into his ear, that this was private property and individuals were not permitted to take pictures without permission.
I asked “Control” how I could get permission and his avatar gave me directions to a reception desk. “Will it be open?”, I asked.
After a pause, I was informed that there were no reception staff on duty. I could come back tomorrow. I deleted the avatar’s photo, shook the security guard’s hand and bade him farewell, very aware of my IC1 privilege.
A sense of place: some of the shop-front hoardings are attractive enough. They are just not shops, though
This exchange emphasised to me the inherent contradiction in the installation of so-called public art in an aggressively private space.
Centrale is a shopping centre with security. If it has any philosophy, it is “buy something or piss off!”
Going down a Stormzy: ‘buy something or piss off!’
The appearance of “public” art in such spaces is a sign, then, of a decline in the world of offline retail generally, and in Centrale in particular.
Business has been so bad these past six years or more (the retail rot had set in long before covid), that Centrale’s owners, Hammerson, ended up selling the centre to their rivals and “Croydon Partners”, Westfield, who already had an important stake in the shopping mall across the road, the Whitgift Centre.
Art here is tolerated as a necessary evil, covering up empty units. It confers on its hosts a patina of virtue and the kudos that comes with the overt patronage of culture.
It is not only “Control’s” anti-art sensibilities that undermine the latest art project to arrive in Croydon, it is the way that the art hides in plain sight, competing as it does with the sensory overload provided by advertising hoardings and displays.
When I was in Centrale, no one else paused to look at the art. Shoppers seemed to scan it briefly, ask themselves subliminally, “What is the product?” and then, question unanswered, move on to their next purchase. Who can blame them? They have come to the Whitgift or Centrale to shop, not to appreciate art.
Furthermore, because I was consciously looking for it, I came across more art that had nothing to do with the latest exhibition. I wonder, for example, how many people notice the rather stunning “Electric-Stormz” portrait of Croydon superstar, Stormzy?
Something to reflect on: part of Rich Simmons’ work outside Allders
The new art in question, on hoardings around the Allders building, has merit. It appears to be well-meant, too.
A look at the website of the curator, Laura Nevill, tells us that this is a collaboration between her and Unibail-Rodamco-Westfield aimed at showcasing the work of local artists. URW’s website tells us that they aim “to maximise shareholder value”.
Nevill explains that she wants to rejuvenate “otherwise dull public spaces”, and given that North End at the front of what once was Allders is an undeniably dull space, her other exhibition works better.
Where once we could look at the window displays of Croydon’s favourite department store, we are now regaled by billboards representing a variety of artistic styles all of which reference Croydon in their own way. When I went on Sunday, last year’s posters were locked away behind padlocked gates, but the latest additions are visible to anyone passing by or coming out of Primark.
Nevill hopes that the art will convey “messages of hope, joy and togetherness and aim to brighten up the town centre whilst helping to raise the profiles of local artists and support the local creative community”. I hope so too, and the more people who see it the better, so go along to North End, have a look inside Centrale, and look for hope and joy in the art that you encounter.
But don’t take photos of it without asking “Control” for permission.
Read more: Westfield begins ‘cover-up’ at Allders – with pop art hoardings
- Ken Towl regularly writes arts reviews for Inside Croydon. To read his previous articles, click here
- If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, or want to publicise your residents’ association or business, or if you have a local event to promote, please email us with full details at inside.croydon@btinternet.com
As featured on Google News Showcase
- Our comments section on every report provides all readers with an immediate “right of reply” on all our content. Our comments policy can be read by clicking here
Inside Croydon is a member of the Independent Community News Network
- Inside Croydon works together with the Bureau of Investigative Journalism, as well as BBC London News and ITV London
ROTTEN BOROUGH AWARDS: In January 2024, Croydon was named among the country’s rottenest boroughs for a SEVENTH successive year in the annual round-up of civic cock-ups in Private Eye magazine
Hello George Orwell, nice to hear that you are well and working hard as ever.
Those whom the Gods wish to destroy, they first make mad.
Quite surprised you got approached at all. I took quite a few photographs of the murals and art in side also the Giraffes when they were there, I also took quite a few of the public realm outside. I was not even aware I required any permission.
Seriously the amount of people walking about with phones on video record ”Control” is better off flogging a dead donkey to a dodgy abbatoir selling horse meat masquerading as pork for a local establishments hot dogs. What was it that Judge said to the Editor ” Well that Horse has well and truly bolted”
I could understand if the place was a target for terrorism etc, but come on, just walking on North End at school kick out, Shoplifter happy hours, or, when those doing the crack withdrawal fast walk are on a mission, ( not to mention those on the faith mission) is in itself an exercise in terror dodging. Having to do that slowly and stopping every few yards I find taking a photo an excellent reason for a breather and to relax the rate rate.
I am sure URW can have a logical word with ”Control” as those photo’s and videos are regular features on all the modern social media sites and shared over the world by Kids, Kidults, Adults (perhaps becoming a minority species in Croydon?) and us more sedate relaxed, and not quite horizontal (yet) residents.
Who would think that a shopping centre would shun good publicity when its free! Go figure.
“Maximise shareholder value” = “sell” ?
REAL art is a town full of open shops, clean streets and happy people. Remember that in Croydon? Now that is a picture we’d all rather gaze at, not some wiggly line that has come out of a spray can nozzle. Come on – the human race can do better than this.
What an excellent memory you have.