CROYDON COMMENTARY: As the inquiry into Croydon Council’s Compulsory Purchase Order for the Westfield and Hammerson development of the Whitgift Centre enters its second week at Fisher’s Folly, SUSAN OLIVER, left, asks what it may be doing to the town’s reputation for doing business
More than 150 businesses are affected by Croydon’s Compulsory Purchase Order, or CPO, which entered its second week of hearings at Bernard Weatherill House today. There have been 141 objections lodged against the CPO, under which our local council is endeavouring to buy up properties to enable a development scheme to go ahead.
If you read the objections – and I encourage you to do so – it becomes clear that this is not a joyous happening in our town.
This is happening to the business community of Croydon, part and parcel of the town centre, who have created significant value here and have invested millions over the years, not only in bricks-and-mortar but also in jobs and training of town’s people. They have been part of the general economy and contributed financially through business rates, VAT and taxes.
Many of these businesses decided to stay in Croydon after the 2011 riots. Some suffered in the riots, most endured a business downturn afterwards. There may have been some financial uncertainty at that time but they opted to stay, helping the town and its people weather that storm, much more than anything the politicians could do.
Given that, it is astonishing that these businesses are being treated in such a callous way. It is not enough to justify this approach by dismissing the businesses, and some of their CPO objections, as being obstacles in the path of “progress”.
Let’s bring this down from an intellectual level: how would you feel if your house was under threat of a CPO? Or if you needed to sacrifice your business, job or way-of-life for the sake of a super-mall?
This is more than just a legal snarl, we are talking about people’s livelihoods and investments. It’s okay for businesses to want to protect their investments – after all, these investments helped to strengthen the town.
Businesses under threat of possession have a lot to lose such as the following:
- Legal costs invested in setting up business and buying the leasehold
- Future financial increases of the leasehold itself
- Money that would have been made while trading
- Financial insecurity due to being relocated
- Loss of identifiable location which shoppers have become used to
- Loss of any investment made in the physical aspect of the property (in the case of Superdry, a renovated frontage)
- A thousand and one things that I haven’t thought of
After Croydon has pissed off so many businesses, will any of them ever want to return?
This question really strikes to the heart of the insecurity that this deal is creating. Businesses want security, and yet here in Croydon we are removing that security. How much can these businesses take before they just decide to leave altogether?
Based on previous, and not very wel-handled, CPOs in Croydon, some people argue that some of the objections may be vexatious, from businesses who are just angling to get a bigger slice from the pay-out. But if that were the case, why are successful businesses which are not under direct threat objecting?
Weatherspoons is such a business. The successful pub chain is only being asked for access during construction, but they still lodged a strongly worded complaint. Short and to the point (unusually for lawyers), their objection accuses Croydon Council, the “acquiring authority”, of failing to show that the CPO is necessary, of failing to consult, and failing to try to acquire the rights by agreement. This reflects poorly on the way the matter has been handled by the council, and therefore reflects poorly on Croydon.
There may be other business people who feel the same way, but don’t feel like paying a lawyer to make an objection.
The sum-total of all this is that the reputation of Croydon as a place to do business must be taking a real beating. And this is progress?
- How MP for Whitgift Foundation has lobbied ‘Inspector Blight’
- Ten compelling questions on the Whitgift Centre CPO
- Borough Solicitor issues elected councillors with CPO gagging order
- Inside Croydon Events: for dates and links to what’s happening in and around Croydon, updated daily, click here
Inside Croydon: Named among best regional media campaigns, 2014.
- Croydon’s only independent news source, based in the heart of the borough: 729,297 page views in 2014.
- If you have a news story about life in or around Croydon, a residents’ or business association or local event, please email us with full details at email@example.com