After a five-year battle against a deep-pocketed developer, aided and abetted by Croydon Council’s planning department, residents on Downsview Road in Upper Norwood have claimed victory in the High Court.
But they now face financial ruin because of the huge costs of running the case.

Five-year battle: residents of Downsview Road took their case to the High Court, and won
The dispute centred on a planning application submitted by Hambridge Investments Ltd to build nine flats on the site of a Downsview Road bungalow.
However, this land — along with neighbouring bungalows, including 283 and 285 Beulah Hill — forms part of the original Beulah Hill Estate, which neighbours claimed is protected by a 100-year-old legal covenant.
This restriction, established during the estate’s original planning, was known to the developer and planning officials from the outset, according to Peter and Caroline Fenech, whose home is next door to the proposed site.
The developer decided to roll the dice, guessing that a lengthy and expensive challenge from residents to any planning permission granted by the council would be unlikely. Croydon Council granted planning permission for 19 Downsview Road in July 2020.
Concerned about the impact on the character of the area, the strain on local infrastructure and the principle of upholding legally binding agreements, the Fenechs formed a small group of residents to challenge the plans. Continue reading →